-
Wishing Non-Muslims On Holi, Diwali, Easter, Halloween, Thanksgiving
Assalamualaikum
Main Ghair-muslim ky tehwaar ky mutaliq Janab Ghamidi Sahab ka view tafseel sy parh chuki hun main Kuch tehwaar pe itlaqi surat chahti Hun….Jaisy Holi, Diwali, Easter, Holloween aur Thanksgiving…in 5 festivals main se kis pe Apne Hindu yah Christian friends ko wish Kiya ka sakta hai?
-
8 Replies
-
Wishing Non-Muslims On Holi, Diwali, Easter, Halloween, Thanksgiving
updated 1 year ago
3 Members
·
8
Replies
-
please see Discussion 68943
-
Boht shukria lakin mazrat chahti Hun In discussion ko main parh chuki hun Asooli bt samjh agai hai lakin itlaq Kr k janna chahti Hun jaisy ky:
1- “Diwali celebrated Rama’s eventual defeat of the evil spirit Ravana, and his triumphant return to his home also after a heroic rescue of his wife Sita, an incarnation of the goddess Lakshmi, Birthday of Lakshmi (dedicated to the worship of the Hindu goddess of wealth Lakshmi.), Southern India celebrates it as the day that Lord Krishna defeated the demon Narakasura.
2- Holi celebrated foe the eternal and divine love of the god Radha and Krishna, Additionally, the day also signifies the triumph of good over evil, as it commemorates the victory of Vishnu as Narasimha Narayana over Hiranyakashipu.
3- Easter is an important Christian festival – it’s when Christians celebrate the resurrection of Jesus Christ. The Bible says that Christ died on a cross on a day called Good Friday. Was buried for three days. According to the Bible, Jesus was then resurrected and came back to life on Easter Sunday. Easter actually originated as an ancient pagan celebration of the spring equinox. In Christianity, the day was dedicated to observing the resurrection of Jesus Christ, celebrated around the time of the Jewish Passover.
4- In 609 A.D. Pope Bonafice IV established the Catholic feast of All Martyrs’ Day in honor of the early Roman martyrs, and this feast was later expanded by Pope Gregory III to include all saints and is still practiced today on November 1st as All Saints’ Day (known also as Hallowtide or All Hallows), dead comes to home that day so to avoid them celebrate Holloween.
5- Thanksgiving…The event that Americans commonly call the “first Thanksgiving” was celebrated by the Pilgrims after their first harvest in the New World in October 1621. This feast lasted three days and was attended by 90 Native American Wampanoag people and 53 survivors of the Mayflower (Pilgrims).
In reasons k elawa b shaid celebrate kiye jte Hun gy lakin kis pe wish Kr skte hain kis pe nahi
-
Based on what you have written, for the last two, there is no issue. For others, you can wish generic greetings like happy holidays, etc.
-
https://ghamidi.com/videos/is-it-permissible-to-celebrate-basant-3262
Is video ma aur Kuch ask Ghamidi forum ki discussion main b Kaha Kya Diwali wish Kr sakte hain Kaha gya Kuch ka believe ha nahi Kr skte…tu confusion hai…Asal main krna chahye wish yah nahi jaisy is video ma b Holi Diwali Christmas k halwe sy Kaha gya k Holi ha rang Daly jaty Diwali ha dye jalye jaty phir tu wo b mana Lene chahye tu Janab Ghamidi Sahab ne Kaha aisy he har festival ko dekhana chahye…shirk tu phir in sb festivals main hai zahir na b ho lakin agr Ram k return k lye hai tu Ram ko wo log god mante in pe wishing humra is ma Shamil hona nai Hoga?
Ap bhi agr Kuch rehnumai Kr sakain is mamle main.
JAZAK ALLAH
-
Main is maamlay par Ghamidi Sahab ki videos kai sath apni raye bh share kar chuka hun neechay walay thread main. Aisay maamlat jinka taluk history kai un pehluon sai hoo jo ab haqiqi tor pai wazeh na hon aur un par do nukta-e-nazar ki gunjaish mojud hoo aur na hi koe wazeh hurmat nazar aa rahi hoo, wahan pai maamla fard ki apni raye aur apnay rujhan pai hi chora jayega.
-
-
Jee sir lakin yeh bt waziah nahi hovi thi aik tarh yeh ky wish Kr skte hain aur dosri tarh jb btya ky false goddess Lakshmi ki birthday ky Liye b manaya jata ha tu Apne Kaha us surat ma perhaiz Kr lein…lakin jb Apne Kaha koe waziah hurmat b nahi ha tu wish krne main masla nahi hai aur ram ka return tha tu wo return k lye manate tu wo dono k Liye manate hain tu Kya phir b wish Kya ja skta hai?? Aur Kya Holi aur easter k lye b wish Kr skte hain?
-
Main is mutaliq wazeh nahi hosaki Asool tu samjh agya ha lakin sawal khaas tehwaar ki Mubarak bad sy mutaliq krna chahti hn agr mere dost hain Jo Hindu hain tu Kya main unko Holi aur Diwali wish Kr skti hun Happy Diwali aur Happy Holi keh Kr…jb ky wo Diwali ram ky return aur goddess Lakshmi ki birthday dono ky Tor pr manate hain dono same day pe hain tu Kya krna chahye is surat main Kya phir b wish Kr skti hun Happy Diwali Happy Holi. Aur kaam b jis company main hai waha Hindu aur Christians colleges b hain…muje Kya krna chahye please Kuch rehnumai kijye
-
Agar Yai baat apko wazeh hai kai jahan aap reh rahi hain wahan yai tehwar kisi daiwi/daiwta ki paidaish kai liya hi manaya jaa raha hai aur us main koe do raye bh mojud nhi hain, toh us surat main ijtinab ka hi mashwara diya jayega. Aisi surat main apnay friends/colleagues ko yai bataya jaa sakta hai kai aap unko khush daikhna chahtay hain har haal main and that you wish them best in every scenario laikin shirk ki wajah sai is tehwar main aap shirkat nhi kar saktin. Happy Diwali ki jagah kuch aur alwfaz bh istemal kiya jaa saktay hain jin sai aap shirk ki mubarakbaad sai bh door rahain aur apnay sentiments bh phoncha dain jaisay “khush raho” ya unko koe dua dai dii jaye generic form main. Yai sab kiya jaa sakta hai.
-
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
