Wishing Happy DiwaliPosted by Dhruv on November 13, 2021 at 6:26 am
Hindu celebrate happy diwali to celebrate return of Ram to his kingdom….isn’t it promoting polythesthic view point by saying happy diwali to them…please specifically tell about happy diwali…is it permissible or not
November 13, 2021 at 7:18 am
I understood that the present form of a celebration matter. The word “diwali” doesn’t contain any word which is realted to shirk. It was a history according to them and also Ram won’t come again according to them too. So now It’s just a festival which is being celebrated in India since many years. Now if someone does polytheism it doesn’t matter until and unless you are not taking part in it. So if you celebrate or attend places where diwali is being celebrated it’s alright. Cause the word diwali doesn’t contain any word which is related to shirk. And also the celebration is about lightning diyas, distributing foods. I also believe same with holi, halloween, chirstmas and new year.
We have to see the present form of celebration of a festival. No matter what is the origin or some may do shirk in these festivals too nd that’s a different thing. But we have to see what the festival is about in the present form. Like holi is a festival of colors. So now if some involve shirk in it thats a different thing.
So yeah brother This is what I’ve understood from ghamidi sb.’s view .
November 15, 2021 at 3:19 am
If the basis of celebrating Diwali is based on polytheism i.e. purely celebrated for some diety only.
Form what I’ve I understood, Celebration of return of ram is a celebration of the return, not a celebration of diety or polytheism itself. Therefore, Happy Diwali can be said to other people. But at the end, it is an ‘ijthadi application‘ and two people may differ on it’s application.
Please listen to the following responses of Ghamidi Sahab very carefully and more than once if possible, to grasp the concept very clearly.
January 23, 2023 at 7:25 am
Lakin sir Wikipedia pe religious background se mutaliq iski sari history majood ha kuch indians ye samjhte hain Ram k return k lye kuch lakshmi goddess ki birth ki khushi ma manate hain kuch krishna se mutaliq krte hn isko tu different believe hain kya humra inko wish krna theek hoga jb k kuch isko lakshmi ki birthday k lye b manate hn
January 26, 2023 at 1:30 pm
It is an ‘ijthadi application‘ and two people may differ on it’s application. So if one considers it to be pure polytheism on the baiss of his/her research, then he/she should avoid saying this to others.
January 26, 2023 at 2:31 pm
Ijtahdi application kaisy hogi sir yahan bt shirk ki ha bht sensitive mamla ha aur jb ye bt waziya ha k wo log is lye manate hn he festival google pe internet ma openly detail majood ha tu kaisy ko differ kr skta ha wo b parhy usko pta chal jay ga phir is mamly ko aisy chorna tu thek nai k koe b apni marzi sy kr ly jb k Janab Ghamidi sb ne kaha shirk hoga agr kisi festival ma agr uski base shirk ha tu phir nai wish krain na shamil hun gy lakin agr koe mosmi tehwar ha yaha Hazrat Issa ka birthday ha phir thk ha
lakin aik jaga unhon ne kaha agr us tehwar ka taluq mazhab se ha tu dekhna chahye kya ha is ka mtlb kya hoga?
jaisy agr unke false god wapis aye jeet kr ram sita tu us khushi ma manate tu khushi tu ha unki wapsi ki lakin kon aya false god. phir un ki goddess lakshmi ki birthday ha
ye mazhabi link ha tu kya asol hona chahye
ijtihad pe tu ghalat faisla b kr ly ga insan
January 26, 2023 at 2:47 pm
Ji koe baat nhi agar ijtehad ghalat bh hogaya toh. Chunkay yai wapsi ki celebration hai, na kai shirk ki celebration, toh is main do raye hoo sakti hain aur is main har shaks ko apni tehqeeq aur apni hasasiyat kai mutabiq mukhlis faisla karna chaiyai. Chunkay Aslan shirk karna haram hai, toh maire raye main mehaz unhain mubarakbad dainay main kisi qisam kai shirk ka irtekab nhi hoo raha banday ki taraf sai.
January 26, 2023 at 2:54 pm
aur isi festival ko false goddess lakshmi ki birthday k lye manaya jata tu us mutaliq apki kya raye ha kiun k Hazrat issa ki birthday wish tu kr skte h. kiun k hum apni tarf se krain k ALLAH k nabi hn lakin inki goddess ko kis lehaz se wish krain
January 26, 2023 at 3:10 pm
ji us surat main ijtenab hi karna chaiyai.
January 24, 2023 at 7:24 am
January 26, 2023 at 3:16 pm
Jee boht shukria
The discussion "Wishing Happy Diwali" is closed to new replies.