-
Why Did God Create Human Beings At All?
(Long question)
Let me lay the foundation first.
In Islamic belief, Allah is eternal, beyond time and space.
He created time — which began with the creation of the universe.
He created space — the dimensions that hold everything we know.
He created matter and energy — through the simple command: “Kun” (Be).
Now, I am not satisfied with the statements like “He created humans to worship Him” or “He created humans to test them”.
If God is Al-Aleem (All-Knowing) and Al-Ghani (Free of all need), then He knows everything about me and yet gains nothing from me worshipping Him, or even existing in the first place. So… why create me? Why create the universe? Why create anything at all?
Why build an entire system — galaxies, life, death, angels, jinn, Judgment Day, Jannat, Jahannam — only to run a test whose outcome is already known to Him?
Some say, “Maybe God created because he wanted to see what would happen if free will was given to conscious beings.”
But that would imply God was curious — and curiosity implies not knowing, which clashes with the very definition of being All-Knowing.
And it gets even more strange when you think about how different God is from us.
We live in time. We experience things second by second — pain, joy, heartbreak, boredom, suspense.
But God is outside time. He already knows the entire timeline of every soul. There’s no suspense. No waiting. No unfolding. It’s all one eternal “now” to Him.
So I have to ask:
Is creation even interesting to God?
Because for us, it’s a journey. For Him, it’s already known.
If God doesn’t feel curiosity, thrill, suspense — and if nothing changes in Him whether He creates or doesn’t — then what’s the point?
A motive implies desire. But if you desire, that means you’re lacking something — and perfection lacks nothing.
So if Allah is truly perfect…
Why want anything at all?
Why create?
Some will say, “The purpose is for us to worship Him.”
But again — why does He want to be worshipped?
Does He need validation? (Of course not.)
And if He already knows who will pass and who will fail… then why create those who will fail at all?
And here’s where the real weight kicks in:
Islam doesn’t just say, “Some will fail.”
It says, some will fail and be in Hell forever.
Forever.
I wouldn’t wish eternal Hell even on the worst criminals. Even Hitler.
Ane the Quran isn’t vague about Hell. It’s described in terrifying, detailed, raw language. Eternal fire. Boiling water. Skin that burns and is replaced again and again. Anguish, regret, pain beyond comprehension.
And yet… Allah still created people knowing some of them would commit kufr and He will throw them in Hell? (Contradictory to his Most-Merciful definition?)
That, right there, is the paradox that haunts me.
Some say that before we were born, Allah created us temporarily and asked, “Am I not your Lord?”, and we all said yes.
But our memory was wiped to keep the test fair.
Still — if that happened, can I not opt out?
I didn’t consciously sign anything in this life. Can I cancel that ancient contract now or maybe in afterlife if I pass the test?
Can I say, “Ya Allah, I don’t even want Jannah. I just want to cease to exist”?
Would He accept that?
I’m not asking this out of arrogance. I’m asking this as a being who feels. Who thinks. Who is tired. Who doesn’t understand why this story needs to be told in the first place — especially by an Author who already knows the ending.
So again I ask:
Why did God write this story?
Why include those who are destined to burn forever?
Why demand worship if He needs nothing?
Why test if He already knows?
Why create… at all?
-
11 Replies
-
Why Did God Create Human Beings At All?
updated 1 month ago
5 Members
·
11
Replies
-
The reality is that God did it. He created the universe and then created the humans to test them and to worship Him. He will judge them on the day of Judgement. This is what he has told us in His book. This has been done, no matter we like it or not.
This is not His test of knowledge. He created all this for us and let us progress towards our end. He knows everything doesn’t conclude that it is unnecessary, because it is not for His knowledge, but for ourselves. We have to strive to reach our destination.
Of course, God did not need to do this, but He chose to do it, so He did.
-
Please also refer to the following video from 1:53 to 13:20
-
Please also refer to the video below from 3:08 to 7:26
-
That’s very fin question and this question haunted religion for a long time and still it is a really good philosophical question. Religious people can answer that “God knows everything and every timeline. But God’s knowledge doesn’t contradict the free will.” That seems funny and unreal to me. Even in the Quran there is story where Hazrat Musa and harun went on a beach and harun killed a kid there. Allah said that it is better because that boy was going to disobey and distract his parents in. Future. That incident clearly goes against the concept of free will in Islam.
-
Allah is given you complete conscious and free will to live in the earth and you will definitely die…
So Allah only wants from you to live consciously, for your understanding if you would not like someone to steal from you, harass you, destroy your dignity, separate you from your family, humiliate your loved ones, somebody weigh less then you should not do those things to others. because it is inbuilt in human being conscious (Good and Bad).
And if you think that you are not coming directly from sky and emerge directly adult from some reaction inside soil then you have to think that some rational is behind it
And definitely you’ll find a perfect coincidence that sun is perfectly distanced from earth, the rotation of earth is perfect for your life. it also not possible if moon is not there and you exists. Also oxygen is available in perfect percentage. All things are in a perfect coincidence. Even slightest changes and you were not existed. If you believe in this perfect coincidence live joyfully your life.. in perfect coincidence
-
One part of my question still feels unanswered:
If Allah is Al-‘Aleem (All-Knowing) and Al-Ghani (free of all need), why create anything at all? (The actual reason?)
A motive usually implies desire, but desire can imply lacking something, and a perfect being lacks nothing. If Allah needs nothing and gains nothing, why choose creation OVER non-existence?
The Quran says our purpose is to worship Allah and to pass the test. Just like angels’ purpose is to follow His command. That explains our purpose, not necessarily why Allah CHOSE to create. Why create beings who must go through tests, suffering, and the possibility of Jahannam? (What was His thought-process behind all this?)
Existence of anything makes no sense to me. I would prefer it if nothing existed at all. But since there’s a universe in place, even if we assume that there is such an all-knowing intelligent entity (creationism as opposed to evolution) that we call Allah, who is responsible for the creation of this reality, I would prefer it to not have created anything in the first place, or just create heaven with no tests if the entity is actually the Rehman and Raheem that it claims to be…
-
Arif Iqbal, your reply doesn’t answer my question, brother.
-
This reply was modified 1 month ago by
ilhaam shaikh.
-
This reply was modified 1 month ago by ilhaam shaikh.
-
This reply was modified 1 month ago by
-
-
You should consider it a perfect coincidence live your life joyfully and live your life joyfully
-
God has not told us why He chose to create the universe and its creatures. We can only hope that, if He wills and permits us, we will receive the answer directly from Him in the Hereafter.
-
I understand the answer that Allah has not explicitly told us why He chose to create. But that leaves the central part of my question unanswered.
What explains the choice of creation rather than no creation at all? Has any Muslim scholar tried to figure this out?
I find it difficult to accept that this question is simply unknowable, because this is not a minor detail about the unseen. It concerns the very nature and act of Allah as Al-Khaliq, the Creator. If the Qur’an presents Allah’s nature and attributes so extensively, shouldn’t such a fundamental question have at least been addressed?
Does the Qur’an explicitly answer why Allah chose creation over no creation, despite having absolutely no need for anything? If so, where exactly?If the answer is genuinely “Allah has not told us,” then why would such a fundamental question about the Creator Himself be left unanswered?
Could this absence reasonably be used as an argument against the claim that the Qur’an is a complete and sufficient explanation from an all-knowing God? If this question is central to understanding why reality exists at all, why is there no clear revelation addressing it?
You say perhaps we may receive the answer in the Hereafter. What is the basis for believing that? Has Allah or the Prophet ﷺ said that this particular unanswered question will be explained to us then?
Did any of the Sahaba ever ask the Prophet ﷺ a question equivalent to this: “If Allah needs nothing, why did He create at all?” If they did, what was the answer? If not, do we know why such a seemingly fundamental question was never recorded?
Are there examples from the followers of previous prophets asking this same question, or something substantially similar? And if so, what answer did revelation give them?I would very much appreciate if a detailed response on each sub-question is also provided. I appreciate what you’re doing and will donate to your platform if I’m satisfied, inshallah.
-
-
Dear brother, the Quran is there. If you can find out the answer to this question, you may let us know.
The Quran does not answer all the questions. It asks us to know our limits; do not ask for the things you cannot apprehend.
See the following verse:
وَيَسْأَلُونَكَ عَنِ الرُّوحِ ۖ قُلِ الرُّوحُ مِنْ أَمْرِ رَبِّي وَمَا أُوتِيتُم مِّنَ الْعِلْمِ إِلَّا قَلِيلًا
They ask you about the rūḥ [that is being revealed to you]. Tell them: This rūḥ is a directive of my Lord, and you have been given very little knowledge of such facts
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
