Ask Ghamidi

A Community Driven Discussion Portal
To Ask, Answer, Share And Learn

Home › Forums › General Discussions › Is Belief In God A Natural Instinct Or A Product Of Social Conditioning?

  • Is Belief In God A Natural Instinct Or A Product Of Social Conditioning?

    Posted by Shah Mir on November 12, 2026 at 1:42 pm

    I have been living in England for some time now, and I have noticed a significant difference between Pakistani society and British society when it comes to belief in God and religion.

    In Pakistan, religion and the belief in God play a very important role in people’s lives. However, here in England, I have noticed that, for many people, God and religion do not seem to have the same importance. There also seems to be less awareness of the concept of the Hereafter and accountability after death.

    This observation has made me think about an argument often presented by atheists: that the belief in God and religion is not necessarily a natural human reality, but rather something that becomes strong because of the environment and society in which a person is raised.

    My question is: If belief in God were a natural human instinct or an inherent truth, why is there such a significant difference between people in Pakistan and England? There are many basic human instincts and natural realities that remain the same in people regardless of their country, culture or environment. Why does belief in God not appear to be equally strong or universal in the same way?

    Does this difference suggest that religious belief is mainly shaped by social and cultural conditioning, or is there another explanation for this phenomenon from an intellectual and philosophical perspective?

    Dr. Irfan Shahzad replied 2 hours, 8 minutes ago 2 Members · 5 Replies
  • 5 Replies
  • Is Belief In God A Natural Instinct Or A Product Of Social Conditioning?

  • Dr. Irfan Shahzad

    Scholar November 12, 2026 at 9:49 pm

    It is natural to think of a creator when we encounter something created. Whenever we see a piece of craftsmanship, our instinctive response is to ask who made it. The same instinct leads us to inquire about the Creator of the universe, which is not a random or chaotic phenomenon but an ordered and structured reality. The idea of God, therefore, arises naturally from human observation and reflection.

    European society, however, has undergone a historical transformation: from rigid religiosity to a reaction against religion, and eventually to indifference towards it. This social conditioning has, to some extent, shaped people’s thinking, suppressing their natural inclination to ask what seems to be an obvious question: Who created the universe, and what is the purpose of life?

  • Shah Mir

    Member November 14, 2026 at 4:37 pm

    I understand your explanation regarding the historical development of European society, and I have looked into this history myself. I agree that Europe went through the transformation you have described, from strong religious influence to a reaction against religion and eventually towards greater secularisation.

    However, my question goes a little deeper.

    If we consider the Islamic understanding that this entire universe has been created for a purpose, and that human life is fundamentally a test (trial and accountability), then surely human nature and the inclination to recognise its Creator must have some fundamental significance in this whole scheme.

    My question is: Can this natural inclination really be so weak that a particular historical experience, a series of social developments, or even a collective decision made by a society can substantially change or suppress something so fundamental to human nature?

    In other words, if the recognition of God is an inherent part of human nature and human existence itself has been designed around this test, how can the cultural and historical decisions of certain societies become powerful enough to make entire generations indifferent to God, religion and the Hereafter?

    Does this not raise a deeper question about whether this inclination is genuinely an inherent part of human nature, or whether religious belief is largely shaped by the society and environment in which a person is raised?

  • Dr. Irfan Shahzad

    Scholar November 18, 2026 at 12:57 am

    No doubt, human beings are influenced by their environment. However, the idea of a Creator is something that comes naturally to them. Another natural human instinct is the sense of justice and the desire for retribution and recompense. When people see that justice is not fully served in this world, they wish that they could establish complete justice themselves. However, the certainty that there is an afterlife in which absolute justice will prevail is not an innate human intuition; rather, it is knowledge conveyed to them through religion. In the absence of this revealed knowledge, they can only long for such a reality without knowing for certain that it exists.

    • Shah Mir

      Member November 18, 2026 at 5:11 pm

      Does the environment have the power to override human nature? How can a collective decision or the influence of society change or suppress something that is considered a fundamental natural inclination of human beings? In other words, can social and cultural influences become stronger than our innate human nature?

  • Dr. Irfan Shahzad

    Scholar November 18, 2026 at 11:12 pm

    Even when human beings are shaped and influenced by social and cultural constructs, they can still sense what their innate nature tells them. This is why they are capable of questioning and changing social and cultural influences. When they adopt something contrary to their innate nature, they eventually feel dissatisfied with it once they become fully aware of its unnatural character.

You must be logged in to reply.
Login | Register