-
Sura Aadyaat?
When it comes to the word dabha, traditional tafseer use it to refer panting horses…some translate it panting camels…as both of the interpretations are found in hadees narrations….some shia scholars translate it as panting people (in battle field)….
Ghamdi sahab has also translated it as panting horses..
My question is traditional tafaseer are backed up by hadees for these translations, what is the argument for ghamdi sahab translating it as horses rather than camel or some other animal or so…. as the upcoming verses do also fit for camel.
And, traditional tafseer have use the verse ” innal insaan li rabi hi laqa nood” in its general sense….
While ghamdi sahab has highly contextualise it and devising an incident that people used to attack eachother for different purposes, but only the quresh were never ever attacked because they have Kabbah under their custody which was an ayyatullah for them if they ever ponder on it….
Why should this reasoning of him be accepted when it is not explicitly mentioned in verses. Isn’t it like injecting words in the translation to make it suit to your narrative?
3rd….the people would never attack quresh because they fear that their idols present in kabah will be thrown out….how was it and ayyatullah for them?
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi