-
Is Bitcoin Perpetual Futures Trading Permissible
Assalamu Alaikum, Respected Ghamidi Sahib,
I would like to seek your guidance regarding the Islamic permissibility of Bitcoin perpetual futures trading. My question concerns this type of financial contract itself, regardless of which exchange offers it.
Scholars such as Mufti Taqi Usmani and the International Islamic Fiqh Academy have raised objections to conventional futures trading, including concerns about ownership, uncertainty (gharar), speculation, and deferred settlement.
References to Previous Ask Ghamidi Discussions
I have reviewed the following discussions:
- Discussion #50049: Crypto Futures Trading
- Discussion #85515: Futures Trading — Leverage and Ownership Requirements
- Discussion #79296: Funding Rate in Crypto Futures Trading
- Discussion #96936: Crypto Perpetual Futures Contract
- Discussion #97295: Futures — Ownership Requirements
I appreciate the explanations provided in these discussions. However, some responses indicate that futures trading, leverage, and selling without ownership are not inherently prohibited, while another response raises an objection to perpetual futures because the underlying asset is not actually exchanged.
I would appreciate clarification on how these responses should be understood together and how they apply specifically to cash-settled Bitcoin perpetual futures contracts.
Clarification Regarding the Authority of Forum Responses
I would also respectfully like to understand whether the scholars and moderators answering questions on this forum are officially authorized by Ghamidi Sahib to represent his religious understanding.
Are their responses reviewed or endorsed by Ghamidi Sahib, or do they represent their own independent scholarly opinions? If a moderator answers my question, should I understand that answer as Ghamidi Sahib’s position or as the moderator’s personal interpretation?
I ask this because some previous responses appear to differ, and I would particularly like to understand Ghamidi Sahib’s own position on this matter.
An Important Clarification Regarding My Research
The following explanation is based on my own research and understanding. I am not a financial expert, and some of the technical details or assumptions I have included may be incomplete or incorrect.
I therefore respectfully request that you or your research team independently examine how these contracts actually operate and correct any misunderstandings in my description before reaching a conclusion regarding their permissibility.
My Understanding of How Bitcoin Perpetual Futures Work
Bitcoin perpetual futures are financial derivative contracts linked to Bitcoin’s market price. Unlike spot trading, these contracts allow traders to take positions on price movements without purchasing or receiving actual Bitcoin.
For example, suppose Bitcoin is trading at $70,000:
- Long position: A trader expecting Bitcoin’s price to rise opens a long position. On a position equivalent to 1 BTC, a rise to $71,000 produces a $1,000 profit before fees, while a fall to $69,000 produces a $1,000 loss.
- Short position: A trader expecting Bitcoin’s price to fall opens a short position. The trader profits if the price falls and loses if it rises.
Traders may use technical analysis, market trends, economic conditions, and other information when making these decisions.
In the cash-settled perpetual futures contracts I am asking about, traders deposit collateral (margin), and profits and losses are settled in a currency such as USDT or USD rather than through delivery of Bitcoin.
These contracts generally have no fixed expiry date, although positions remain subject to margin and liquidation requirements.
Leverage, Fees, and Funding Payments
Perpetual futures commonly offer leverage, allowing traders to control a larger position using a smaller amount of collateral. The precise financial and legal structure of leverage may vary between contracts and platforms.
Exchanges generally charge trading commissions.
Many perpetual futures contracts also involve periodic funding payments between long and short traders, intended to keep the perpetual contract price close to Bitcoin’s spot price. Depending on the funding rate, one side pays the other.
Relationship With the Bitcoin Spot Market
From my understanding, liquidation of leveraged long positions creates selling pressure in the futures market, while liquidation of short positions creates buying pressure.
There may also be connections between futures and spot prices through arbitrage, hedging, and market-making. Futures contracts may serve purposes such as managing financial risk and price discovery.
However, I am not certain about the exact mechanism or extent of these effects. I would appreciate independent verification of this understanding and whether these factors have any relevance to the Islamic ruling.
My Questions
1. The Hadith and its underlying reason (illah)
Regarding the Hadith, “Do not sell what you do not possess” (Jami’ al-Tirmidhi 1232), what were the circumstances in which the Prophet ﷺ gave this instruction?
Should we examine its historical context and underlying reason to understand its application, or should its wording apply literally to every transaction regardless of context?
Was the concern deception, uncertainty, inability to deliver, or disputes? Would this Hadith apply to a cash-settled financial derivative in which delivery of Bitcoin is not promised?
2. Gambling (maysir), uncertainty (gharar), and zero-sum trading
If traders use market analysis, knowingly accept the risks, and enter contracts with clearly defined terms, what specifically would make this trading prohibited gambling or excessive uncertainty?
Is the fact that one trader’s profit corresponds to another trader’s loss sufficient to classify the transaction as gambling?
What distinguishes legitimate financial speculation from prohibited gambling under the Quran and Sunnah?
3. Leverage and funding payments
How should the actual leverage arrangement in these contracts be evaluated? If it does not involve an interest-bearing loan, would it be permissible?
Would periodic funding payments between long and short traders constitute riba? Does the method used to calculate these payments affect the ruling?
4. Ownership and cash settlement
Since cash-settled Bitcoin perpetual futures involve settling price differences without transferring actual Bitcoin, is the absence of Bitcoin ownership itself a reason for prohibition?
Can a financial contract linked to an underlying asset be a legitimate subject of trade without the actual asset being exchanged? Does the absence of an expiry date create any separate Islamic objection?
5. Economic purpose and connection to the underlying market
If perpetual futures serve economic purposes such as hedging, arbitrage, risk management, and price discovery, does that have any relevance to their Islamic permissibility?
Would the ruling differ between someone using these contracts to hedge an existing investment and someone trading them independently to profit from price movements?
6. Clarification of previous Ask Ghamidi responses
In discussions #50049 and #85515, futures trading was described as not inherently prohibited. In discussion #97295, selling without ownership was considered permissible under certain safeguards.
However, in discussion #96936, an objection was raised because no underlying asset was actually exchanged.
Is there a fundamental difference between the contracts being discussed, or is there a difference of scholarly opinion regarding their permissibility? Which of these interpretations reflects Ghamidi Sahib’s understanding?
7. The nature of any prohibition
If Bitcoin perpetual futures trading is impermissible, is the financial contract itself prohibited, or is the prohibition due to particular elements such as interest, gambling, excessive uncertainty, or deception?
If those prohibited elements are absent, could this form of trading become permissible?
8. Practical permissibility of trading and earning a livelihood
If Bitcoin perpetual futures trading is permissible under the Quran and Sunnah, can a Muslim actively trade these contracts to generate income or earn a livelihood?
Would the profits earned through such trading be considered halal?
Can a Muslim engage in both long and short trading, with or without leverage, provided the relevant Islamic requirements are fulfilled?
Are there any specific conditions, restrictions, or practices that a Muslim trader must observe or avoid to ensure that this trading and the income earned from it remain permissible?
My Central Question
After independently examining and verifying how cash-settled Bitcoin perpetual futures contracts actually operate, is this form of trading permissible under the Quran and Sunnah?
- If it is prohibited, which specific religious instruction or principle prohibits it, and what is its underlying reason (illah)?
- If it is permissible, can we practically engage in Bitcoin perpetual futures trading and earn income from it? Under what conditions, if any?
I would sincerely appreciate Ghamidi Sahib’s personal explanation, particularly regarding the Hadith about selling what one does not possess, the nature of cash-settled financial contracts, and the apparent differences between the previous forum responses.
If Ghamidi Sahib is unable to answer personally, I would respectfully request that the responding scholar clarify whether their answer represents Ghamidi Sahib’s established position or their own independent scholarly understanding.
My purpose is not merely to understand the theoretical permissibility of these contracts but also to obtain clear religious guidance on whether I can practically engage in this trading and earn a halal livelihood from it.
I would also be grateful if any errors in my technical explanation could be identified and corrected.
Thank you for your time and guidance.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
Sorry, there were no replies found.