-
Did Prophet (AS) Initiate Collection, Preservation And Compilation Of Hadith?
-
18 Replies
-
Did Prophet (AS) Initiate Collection, Preservation And Compilation Of Hadith?
updated 3 years, 9 months ago
4 Members
·
18
Replies
-
I asked this question in other thread also, but it fits here.. does it mean at least one narrator in the false hadith goes to hell ?
-
Why are you so interested in sending others to hell
-
I think you should ask this question to the Prophet, right ? I am just quoting him.
-
Prophet Muhammad (Peace be Upon Him) said that whoever intentionally associated anything false to Him, He will find His place in Hell.
Now how do you know every narrator did so intentionally?
-
I did not say every narrator .. I said at least one of them. And I am only talking about attributing false statements to the Prophet, something he didn’t say.
-
-
We have many Sahih hadiths which are actually the things which Prophet did not say .. so we can claim that the narrators of those Sahih haidths are going to go to hell ..
-
Do you believe there is Hell or Heaven or even God?
-
No, I don’t. I am just analysing what Prophet said.
-
-
Interestingly Prophet said attributing a false thing to him will make someone reach hell .. isn’t it common for all ? Does it mean that one can attribute false things to others and it is not a sin ? What is the difference b/w knowingly attributing false things to Prophet and knowingly attributing false things to someone else ? Aren’t both wrong ?
-
There is a thing called honest mistake or an honest misunderstanding of something also.
-
But honest mistakes would not cause them to go to hell anyway.. so the context is about deliberately misquoting Prophet vs deliberately misquoting any other random man.. both are immoral actions, right ? Why punishment of hell specific to misquoting Prophet only and not in general ?
-
How do you know that such an action in general is not rebuked in Islam?
-
If it is already a sin to misquote anyone , then what is the need to mention hell specific for misquoting Prophet ?
-
For emphatic purposes, for self-reflection.
-
So, can we assume some of the quotes of the Prophet about killing blasphemers or age of Aisha at the time of marriage which the narrator knew was false (i.e Prophet did not say or act like that), will make the narrator go to hell ..
Can we call such a narrator unreliable at least ? Will we accept his other narrated hadiths ?
-
I am sorry, this is not our way to discuss who’s going to hell and who is not.
We will remind people if they’re doing anything wrong for their self-reflection so that they can revert back to truth during this lifetime.
As mentioned earlier, there could be factors other than intentional misreporting which can lead to actual meaning of Hadith to get blurry. So each Hadith needs to be examined in accordance with Principles of Understanding Hadith, which takes all these factors into account.
-
Does Allah not care that sayings and actions of Prophet are not misquoted ?
-
No.
-
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
The discussion "Did Prophet (AS) Initiate Collection, Preservation And Compilation Of Hadith?" is closed to new replies.
