-
Huqooq Ul Ibaad
Ok then take this example. I light a match to turn on my stove. It falls from my hand- my house burns down and also my neighbours. I didn’t want to burn down his house but now he is asking for money. I live in a small house he had a mansion. Now I die in crippling debt. I have unintentionally infringed his rights and was not able to fulfil them
How can it be fair for me to give my good deeds to him when it was a mistake?
-
4 Replies
-
Huqooq Ul Ibaad
updated 3 years, 8 months ago
2 Members
·
4
Replies
-
In principle, uncontrollable situations do not constitute bad deeds. I can’t objectively comment about the example you used above because there can be many variables. For example, perhaps you knowingly ignored to buy insurance when you still had the chance, which would pay the damages to your neighbor. Or you knew in advance that your stove wasn’t working right and could cause a fire. Or you knowingly ignored to buy a fire extinguisher when you knew that should have – the list can go on.
-
Let’s say for this example all measures were taken except for insurance- but it wasn’t knowingly.
The burning of the mansion itself isn’t sinful. But if we take into account the general narrative it is that any right infringed must be compensated for in this life or you will have to pay for it in the next:
A right has been infringed- property has been damaged
The damage itself wasn’t sinful
But according to huqooq ul ibaad concept since I couldn’t pay the debt- I will be held accountable for it and give back this wealth by exchanging deeds. This does not sit right with me
-
As I stated, uncontrollable situations do not constitute bad deeds. Of course, you must ask the aggrieved party and God for forgiveness in best possible ways.
-
-
Sir, can we say that if a right has been infringed even unintentionally (the actual infringement won’t constitute a bad deed) but the person stands up on the day of judgement asking for payment of his right (debt) we must pay it back. The most we can do in this world is reduce the debt and do as many good deeds as possible to even the scales.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
