-
Ghamidi Sahab Tafsir Surah Bayyinah
Those among the People of the Book and the Idolaters6 [of the Quraysh] who have denied [the Qur’an]7 shall not desist from their stubbornness until [according to their wish] there comes to them a clear sign – that is a messenger from God [descending from the heavens] reciting purified pages in which [are written] clear directives [for them].8 (1-3)
8. Ie., their demand that instead of this messenger and this Qur’an, a messenger of God should bring pages untouched by man and jinn. He should descend while reciting them. It should contain something as precise as the directives written in the tablets of the Torah and not contain the many unrelated anecdotes and discussions found in the Qur’an.
Is Ghamidi sahab writing from the perspecitve of the stubborn ahl kitaab and mushrikeen that the Quran contians unrelated anecdotes? Because aren’t the stories in the Qur’an direclty related and made appropriate for these two groups; but they deny because of their stubborness
-
1 Reply
-
Ghamidi Sahab Tafsir Surah Bayyinah
updated 3 years, 7 months ago
2 Members
·
1
Reply
-
I think this is with reference to the kind of arguments one builds when they are determined to evade the message of truth. Because verse 4 onward answers this point, that when something direct was given to them in the form of pointers, even then they insisted on their perverseness. Also, this was not addressing all the People of the Book and the Idolaters, this was specific to the ones among them who had decided to not use their intellect and to deny the message of Prophet (sws) at all costs.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
