-
Ishaq AS And Ismail AS
How Many Children did Abraham AS have ? Jewish Rabbi claims that Al Tabri also believe that only 1 child there was and his name Ishaaq AS ?? What is Muslim point of view in this regard kindly describe.
-
11 Replies
-
Ishaq AS And Ismail AS
updated 2 years, 11 months ago
4 Members
·
11
Replies
-
Quran is very clear about Ibrahim AS having two sons. Please see Quran 37:99-113.
-
Shukriya…. Why Al Tabri have different view for this ??
-
In my knowledge Al-Tabari doesn’t argue whether or not Ismael AS was also a son of Ibrahim AS. I think largely there’s no argument on this point whether amongst Jews or Muslims.
The debate is whether the son who was offered for sacrifice by Ibrahim AS was Ishaq AS or Ismael AS. Al-Tabari, amongst many others are of the view that it was Ishaq AS. However, in light of the Quran verses I shared above, it’s clear that Ishaq AS was born after the sacrifice incident, so it had to be Ismael AS.
-
How the Giant Scholar like Al Tabri reached on this conclusion if it is clearly mention in Quran… Please describe if have any research on this .
-
Lots of giants in every field of knowledge make lots of mistakes all the time, despite sincere effort. The key is that we attach value to their work and not their popularity or status. Only information received through prophets and messengers of God is infallible – the rest of it is all human work which always has room for error.
-
Bahot Shukriya
-
-
Related: Discussion 1627 • Reply 6005
-
Shukriya
-
-
https://ghamidi.tv/books/zabihkonhai-213
Janaab Amin Islahi’s book on the sacrifice
-
Ji Shukriya
-
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
