-
Do Miracles Have To Be Supernatural?
Is it a given that miracles are not in the sphere of being able to be explained by science? Like the Red Sea parting some people have made a model showing that winds could have done this. This doesn’t have to detract from God causing these winds to move through a natural process.
-
10 Replies
-
Do Miracles Have To Be Supernatural?
updated 3 years, 12 months ago
5 Members
·
10
Replies
-
It is not necessary for miracles at a given time to always remain unexplained by the science.
-
Don’t scientific explanations take away from the veracity and perhaps validity of the miracle? EG it was just a natural event and people made a story around it. Also is it a given that done miracles have to be supernatural? A snake turning into a stick seems impossible but it may not be fit later generations
-
-
I find your question fascinating because if you showed current technology to people from the past they will find it a miracle. But miracle I think is a sign , sign of a all powerful GOD , who has control over everything and the powers of that age are helpless against the GOD , and all their idols are defeated . And from this question springs the question of Quran being a miracle for all people to come ? , and hence a sign of GOD and contains signs of GOD . And I think miracle of Quran is more wonderful and broad then all miracles before it because it is present amoung us all the times , it is a sign and it contains signs , and it overpowers the falsehood as those miracles did , all at the same time . We are blessed to have the Quran amoung us.
-
Miracles are sent with the prophets to catch the attention of the audience rest of the job is done by prophets themselves
-
Yes , but they are a sign , just like the magicians of the firaoun recognized the sign and came to believe in one GOD
-
-
The point is our relationship with Quran is not just a book with commands of GOD , but a sign of GOD , and then the miracles of Quran can be seen , when we think this way.
-
Response by Hassan Ilyas sahab:
https://soundcloud.com/ask-ghamidi/0010-do-miracles-have-to-be-supernatural/s-otsjqF91lhu
-
I guess though that miracles MUST be supernatural because otherwise it would be just as what the people of the past said that it’s magic
-
Also- what about the miracle snot related to itmam e hujjat though- like Jonah and the whale and ashab e kahf? Must they also be supernatural Scheidung to the above statement?
Maybe not
-
I think think those events were originally meant to be shown as miracles to disbelievers, could be their secondary use but not the primary point.
-
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
