Forums › Forums › Epistemology And Philosophy › 6. The Concept Of Return Of Jesus / Isa AS (23 Question Series)
-
6. The Concept Of Return Of Jesus / Isa AS (23 Question Series)
Posted by Faisal Haroon on November 5, 2020 at 9:24 amFollowing videos are from Ghamidi sahab’s Response to 23 Questions series. In these videos he explains the misconception about the the return of Isa / Jesus AS (Second Coming).
Ahsan replied 1 year, 4 months ago 2 Members · 8 Replies -
8 Replies
-
6. The Concept Of Return Of Jesus / Isa AS (23 Question Series)
-
Faisal Haroon
Moderator November 5, 2020 at 9:24 am1- Introduction. From 00:15 to 1:20
2- What is the traditional concept of return of Jesus? From 1:20 to 3:15
3- Is it necessary to believe in prophecies reported in the name of Prophet Muhammad (pbuh) about events before Qiyamah? Description of sources of Deen, Akhbar e Ahad, appreciation of Hadith science and authentic signs of Qiyamah. From 3:15 to 14:30
4- What is the difference between denial of ‘Imaniyat’ and denial of prophecies? Implications of differences in interpretation of Quran and Hadith. From 14:30 to 19:34
5- How can we not appreciate details of rituals and different narrations obtained through Ijma from generation to generation? What is ‘Tawatur al Akhbar’? From 19:34 to 32:30
6- If you are satisfied with a narration that is reported to have been said by Prophet Mohammad (pbuh) and in accordance with Quran, will you accept that narration even if they don’t qualify ‘Tawatur al-Akhbar’? From 32:30 to 38:00
7- How can one jump to the conclusion that if someone rejects a Hadith then that person actually denies prophethood? From 38:00 to end
-
Faisal Haroon
Moderator November 12, 2020 at 10:09 am1- If all scholars agree on a narration to be sahih except one, then shouldn’t we question that one person first? From 0:25 to 7:54
2- What is the process of verification of narrations? From 7:54 to 13:29
3- What is the origin of your dissatisfaction with the concept of return of Jesus? Brief History of Hadith literature and return of Jesus narrations. From 13:29 to 56:64
4- If an event, according to the narrations, is supposed to happen at a given time but does not happen, how will we view that narration? From 56:64 to end
-
Faisal Haroon
Moderator November 19, 2020 at 8:46 am1- Recap of previous video, Hadith narration (sunnah.com/muslim:2897) which tells the exact time of the return of Jesus. From 00:25 to 21:44
2- Explanation of Muslim 2897 , conquest of Constantinople and analysis of its aftermath. From 21:44 to 38:01
3- Isn’t it possible Muslim 2897 is talking about different conquest of Constantinople than the conquest which happened 600 years ago? From 38:01 to 46:10
4- Do you have any other reasons for dissatisfaction? 10 sign of Qiyamah (sunnah.com/muslim:2901a, 2901b) From 46:10 to 58:52
5- Inconsistency in the narration of Muslim 2901. From 58:52 to end
-
Faisal Haroon
Moderator November 26, 2020 at 9:36 am1- Are you dissatisfied with the contents of the narration or Prophet Mohammad’s prophecy itself? From 00:40 to 2:56
2- Is your dissatisfaction based on contradiction in the content of narrations? From 2:56 to 8:32
3- Why don’t you directly deny concept of the return of Jesus? From 8:32 to 11:20
4- Why didn’t you present your doubts on the Ahadith regarding the return of Jesus in your book ‘Meezan’? From 11:20 to 12:33
5- Which Quranic verse raises doubt on the concept of return of Jesus? From 12:33 to 18:51
6- If Allah wishes not to tell us directly about Jesus’ return, then what is the problem? Quranic verses which raise question on the concept of return of Jesus. From 18:51 to 36:49
-
Faisal Haroon
Moderator December 3, 2020 at 8:34 am1- How can you question Allah for not giving information to us about any event? From 01:17 to 7:03
2- Why don’t you question narrators for details of Salah, Zakat, Hajj etc? From 7:03 to 12:13
3- There are certain things for which we don’t question Allah then why on this matter? From 12:13 to 16:25
4- Isn’t it possible that the dialogue in Quran (5:117) refers to the Christians just after 1st coming of Jesus? From 16:25 to 20:38
5- What if Allah is questioning the christians after 400 AD? From 20:38 to 22:36
6- Can it be inferred from verse 4:157-158 that Jesus is still alive hence will be sent to the world again. From 22:36 to 40:00
7- Why do you translate “Inni Mutawafik” to death in Verse 3:55? From 40:00 to 1:01:32
8- In Quran, two time Mutafikka is used as sleep then why we can’t it imply ‘sleep’ here? From 1:01:32 to 1:09:00
9- Discussion in linguistics with respect to subject and object. From 1:09:00 to 1:11:02
10- Meaning of ‘Rafeuka Illaya’ in Quran 3:55? From 1:11:02 to 1:13:24
11- Did Allah give death to prophets himself? From 1:13:32 to 1:14:26
12- Doesn’t the use of ‘Mutwafika’ with ‘Rafeuka Illaya’ show that death was not given? From 1:14:26 to 1:15:34
13- The details are given elsewhere then this ayah where death hasn’t been mentioned From 1:15:34 to 1:17:05
14- Summary of Quranic verse and interpretation of the Return of jesus? From 1:17:05 to end
-
Faisal Haroon
Moderator December 10, 2020 at 11:02 am1- What is difference between the literal meaning and meaning in context? From 00:50 to 8:35
2- Difference in your methodology and traditional Ulema’s methodology. From 8:35 to 11:50
3- Clarification about meaning of ‘zarb’ in verse 4:34. Discussion about linguistics. From 11:50 to 18:06
4- Objection: In Verse 3:40, Quran tells Jesus will speak at age of 40 so it can be inferred that Hazrat Isa will return. Clarification? From 18:06 to 29:00
5- Isn’t Bible corrupted, so how can you argue based on that? From 29:00 to 29:57
6- Objection: Verse 43:61 tells that Jesus is sign of the final hour. From 29:57 to 48:21
-
Faisal Haroon
Moderator December 17, 2020 at 12:03 pm1- Objection: The Verse 4:159 confirms return of Jesus and all people of Book will believe. From 00:25 to 6:02
2- Clarification of the verse 4:159? From 6:02 to 23:30
3- Can we have information that when people will die they will be convinced about truth of Quran? From 23:30 to 25:57
4- Why there is ijma of traditional narrative on verse 4:159? From 25:57 to 30:07
5- Does Quran deny the return of Jesus? From 30:07 to 32:38
6- Our intellect tells us that the birth of Jesus was different from normal, therefore can we not infer he will come again? From 32:38 to 35:15
7- Quran tells that believers of Jesus will be dominant over deniers. However we see Jews controlling economic power. Why is that so? From 35:15 to 37:28
8- Bible also suggests second coming of Jesus. What is your opinion about it? From 37:28 to 52:34
9- How did this concept of return of Jesus originate and how did it spread so widely? From 52:34 to 1:12:00
10- How can common Muslims understand your point of view? From 1:12:00 to end
-
Ahsan
Moderator July 7, 2023 at 8:39 amEpisode 8- Part 134:
00:00- Intro
1:30– Does your hadith project corroborate your opinion?
9:52- Comment on hadith https://sunnah.com/ibnmajah:4081
19:00- Comment on the role of Jesus in the world wrt to Gospel
29:17- Comments on the role of scholars in the correction of ideology
30:00- Rebirth of real monotheism in Christians
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
The discussion "6. The Concept Of Return Of Jesus / Isa AS (23 Question Series)" is closed to new replies.