-
Alcohol During Food Cooking
According to various research, alcohol can retain in food upto 60% depending on alcohol concetration, cooking time etc.
In the video
https://youtu.be/raf8eKjlC2s?t=5421
Ghamdi Sb said that if alcohol retained in food do not induce intoxication then its ok to eat.
Ghamdi sb himself repeatedly said that alchol prohibition has been done completely so I am unable to understand his logic here.
Can you explain it? -
3 Replies
-
Alcohol During Food Cooking
updated 3 years, 5 months ago
2 Members
·
3
Replies
-
Salaam.
This is my understanding from this video.
There is a principle of intoxication that is being addressed. He said if the character is changed from being intoxicating to non-intoxicating by any means then it is ok to consume. Eg, vinegar which is derived from ethanol. The question put forth was is cooking wine is allowed which is not intoxicating? He said that if this ingredient doesn’t cause intoxication in a large amount then it is ok to use in a small amount, for cooking. The original principle still stands. The word wine, alcohol, intoxicants are not, necessarily, used interchangeably.
The premise put forth by the illustrious teacher should be very clear to grasp the answer.
Furthermore, he is also addresses personal likes and dislikes.
For percentage left in the food can be addressed by asking the chef. We can ask him as to how much intoxicant is left, according to his knowledge. Then we can make our decision.
Stay blessed, always
-
The research paper I studied mentioned that alcohol didnot change its formula. On the other hand, vinegar is acetic acid which is totally different.
I agree to his personal like and seems to me more better option in this cases.however, I understood ur point. Thanks for explanation.
-
I am glad that you understood the explanation.
I have to explain further for people who might have further questions.
Vinegar is acetic acid made by AAB bacteria by fermentation of ethanol (alcohol). This is an example of a product derived from an alcohol, which has changed and is halal from a haram, sort of.
The second point is that cooking will burn the alcohol to some extent, as rightly pointed out. The chef can give specifics and so the haram might be halal.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
