-
Preservation Of Old Sciprutres
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=JdtFYxe_hSc&list=PLvDnnnkYLWQcAPC78PcSjpB1cwq2KvgR8&index=131
In above video, Ghamdi sb says that books are preserved to great extent but they have changed things to cut the connections to Bani ismael.
My question is Is there any proof for this statement? secondly Surah Maida ayahs from 12 says that the a part of the books from Injeel and torat has been forgotton so how can Ghamdi sb claim they are preserved to great extent.
-
9 Replies
-
Preservation Of Old Sciprutres
updated 3 years, 4 months ago
3 Members
·
9
Replies
-
The proof of the statement is that there’s no ties to bani Ismael in the present day Bible.
Quran verses 5:12-14 do not say that parts of books have been forgotten. They say that people twist the words in these books and that they have forgotten what they were told to bear in mind. You can draw a parallel with Muslims today – some of us twist the words of Quran in order to prove their points, and a lot of people have forgotten the message of God.
-
Thanks for your response.
If i ever talk to Jews or christians about it, I will never be able to convince that. Coz generally they dont believe that a prophet had to come from Bani Ismael. How can I make the point? -
Urdu tranlsation from website
https://quran.com/5/12-17 shows
اب ان کا حال یہ ہے کہ الفاظ کا الٹ پھیر کر کے بات کو کہیں سے کہیں لے جاتے ہیں، جو تعلیم انہیں دی گئی تھی اُس کا بڑا حصہ بھول چکے ہیںsimilarly ayah 14 urdu translation shows
سی طرح ہم نے اُن لوگوں سے بھی پُختہ عہد لیا تھا جنہوں نے کہا تھا کہ ہم ”نصارٰی“ ہیں، مگر ان کو بھی جو سبق یاد کرایا گیا تھا اس کا ایک بڑا حصّہ اُنہوں نے فراموش کردیIt says jo taleem ya sabaq say mtlab shariat hai phr?
-
There’s no point in trying to debate about bani Ismael and bani Israel. Our effort should be to convince them to read the Quran. For a discussion with them it might be helpful to understand what prophethood really is. Video in the following response might be helpful:
-
Thank you
-
-
I’m not clear … please electorate more.
It’s stated that previous scriptures were corrupted, but also Quran is called the custodian of earlier divine books.
What should be our approach when it comes Psalm, Torah & Gospel?
Thank you.
-
Where is it stated that the previous scriptures were corrupted?
-
Alterations have taken place in historical accounts not in Divine directives.
Thanks much @faisalharoon
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
