-
Birth Of Yahya And Ismail And Ishaq In Relation To Isa AS
Do we assume that all of these births occurred in a non natural way EG the act was not done?
-
10 Replies
-
Birth Of Yahya And Ismail And Ishaq In Relation To Isa AS
updated 3 years, 11 months ago
3 Members
·
10
Replies
-
i didnt understand two things in your question, can you kindly explain
1) difference between ismael and ishmael
2) what make you think the act was not done?-
Sorry I meant ishaaq
That is what my question is
-
ok thanks
-
-
Please clarify your question.
-
We’re all these births miraculous? Did the parents have intercourse or was it like isa عليه السلام?
-
That is what I want to understand. On what basis should we assume this?
-
do we have any basis to assume either way? if these were not miraculous then what about the story of Maryam AS makes us think it was miracuous?
-
-
Yes, we have the Quran verses 19:19-20.
-
That doesn’t mean she couldn’t have gotten married or that she wasn’t married and could’ve had a child the natural way
-
-
The virgin birth of Jesus AS was an established fact way before the Quran. In Quran verses 19:19-20 it is confirmed, not refuted. Then in Quran 3:45 Allah SWT names Jesus AS the son of Mary and reconfirms his virgin birth in 3:47 while also mentioning his other miracles. Finally, this concept has reached us with ijma and tawatur.
With such overwhelming evidence of Jesus AS’s virgin birth, the evidence presented against this view can’t simply be “it doesn’t mean”.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
