A Community Driven Discussion Portal
To Ask, Answer, Share And Learn
Ghamidi sahab says that the fitrah is a source of truth. I have one question. God gave you this fitrah. I concede that definitely it is in the fitrah to believe in a God and that he is truthful. But what is the evidence that this fitrah is a source of truth.At the end of the video he says we should know our limits. I agree. Is it then our limit not to surpass our fitrah?
brother… i read the previous discussion…. and i am still confused that what is the objective of this discussion… i mean it is totally useless in any sense….. and now your question… “What is the evidence that fitrah is the source of truth?”…. don’t you think that if you are against the fitrah that Allah has bestowed you it leads you to be a disbeliever… or if you have believed in the fact that THERE IS REALLY A CREATOR OF UNIVERSE than don’t you think it is ridiculous that either He is lying or not lying (mazAllah) to a tiny little creature on a tiny planet
and the fact that there is a human fitrah
don’t you think what is that fitrah must be a prior discussion for this?
Great objection. The answer would be that if we are being deceived there is nothing we can do.
deceived by whom?…. from ourselves
By the one who gave us the fitrah
brother it seems totally an illogical question (thinking that the Creator is deceiving the creature for unknown reason)…. and how to know that He ain’t deceiving us🙄
If I play Devil’s advocate I can say that the creator has his reasons and he’s made it impossible for you to think about why he would do it.
And the point I’m making is not that we are being deceived or we aren’t. Rather we have no ultimate way of knowing.
Like I wrote above it seems we have to be dogmatic about fitrah and just accept it because we have no other thing to follow
can you please explain that what is this Fitrah in your sense ( i have heard Ghamidi sb)… but i want to know what do you think what is fitrah?
The innate knowledge of God and him being truthful
and you are believing that there is a fitrah in human personality….?… do you have any evidence for that🤔
Well if it is just nature then everything has a fitrah.
Human nature would have this knowledge
ok bro… no one can have anything from this discussion….. May Allah give hadayah to all of us❤️
I think the issue is wanting to know ultimate knowledge.
As a limited human being it is impossible for me to know a reality like God or understand his intentions and motives.
So perhaps I shouldn’t be arrogant enough to raise doubt about his truth when he himself has told us that he is the truth.
It’s just the ‘what if?’ and ‘how can we know for sure?’ which is discomforting.
It’s a long debate, I can help you to understand this If you are from Pakistan, we can talk on the phone. Because I don’t have much writing skills
Sure, you can check your dms إن شاء الله
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.