-
Sunnah And Hadees
how can sunnah be the primary source of religion but not the hadees…..?…..and how can we know that sunnah is preserved…. didn’t the sunnah reached the subcontinent or other places through hadees?….
-
4 Replies
-
Sunnah And Hadees
updated 2 years, 11 months ago
3 Members
·
4
Replies
-
Because the Sunnah was initiated by The Prophet himself and the Sahaba adopted that sunnat. But the Hadith was initiated by Muhadiseen (Hadith Collectors) and not the Prophet and neither the Sahaba. Sunnat is preserved in the Amaal(Actions) of the Ummat. Sunnat reached us through the Practice of Muslims in Subcontinent. This Sunnat has reached us by collective unifying consensus of the Ummat and transmitted through Generations from the Companions of the Prophet to their Companions and so on. But Hadith has no such consensus within the Ummat and neither did it reached us Through Uninterrupted continuity in transmission.
-
But how can we know that what Sunnah is part of our religion….there is a possibility of biddat in sunnah too…. and about hadees….hadees was preserved too by muhadassin (true hadees through the chains of narrators)… and also yhere could be doubts on the sunnah… it isn’t like Quran (in a clear cut manner)
-
In The Quran Explicitly, Allah orders the Prophet to Follow the Sunnat of Prophet Ibraheem. This Sunnat of Salat, Roza, Zakat and Hajj was the Sunnat of Ibraheem and all the Prophets after him… Even Before the Prophet Ibraheem all Prophets used to offer Salat, pay Zakat and observe fasting etc as stated in the Quran. The Preservation of Sunnat is similar to the Quran which reached us through consensus of Ummat & Mass Transmissions within generations over time. There is a Possibility of innovation in almost every aspect of deen and that can be checked and verified by comparing with the Actions and Consensus of the Ummat…On the other hand, There is is no such Consensus on Hadith Books or Muhadiseen let alone on a Sahi Hadith…. The Shia Reject the Muhadiseen and their books & the ahadith in them, belonging to Sunni School, Imam Bukhari , Muslim etc…They have their own Muhadiseen and Hadith Books..Al Kafi etc Also the Criteria for Judging the Hadith as Sahi is entirely different in Shia School as compared to Sunni School. The Doubts on Sunnat can be cleared by comparison with the Consensus of Ummat similar to the Quran..
God knows Best!
-
-
The mode of transmission of Sunnah is same as the Quran – ijma and tawatur. Please watch the following video to understand the difference between Sunnah and Hadith.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
