-
Can A Person Claim Another Person's Bad Deeds?
Salam.
Kya koi shakhs akhirat main kisi aur ke gunah ka azaab apne sarr le sakay ga? Aur agar ye mumkin hai to kya aik insaan poori insaniat ka azaab khud k sar le kar baqi sabko jannat ka rasta dilwa sakta hai?
Agar uss shakhs ka apna kirdar relevant hai to farz karlijiye k wo aik aam musalman hai jo sab faraiz pooray karta hai, quran ko behtar se bahtar samajhne ki koshish karta hai, ilkhaqi taur pe awam un-naas main achi raye rakhta hai, aur saadqi aur zuhd ki zindagi basar karta hai.
Main jaanta hu k aese sawal se shadeed entitlement aur takkabur ki boo aati hai, magar farz karlijiye k uss shakhs ki niyat sirf baqi sab ki nijaat hai. Kya aesi koi soorat e haal paida ho sakti hai?
JZK
Salam.
-
4 Replies
-
Can A Person Claim Another Person's Bad Deeds?
updated 2 years, 9 months ago
5 Members
·
4
Replies
-
Wsalam,
Quran is very clear that every one has to give their own account and no injustice will be done.
You can read more about belief in hereafter in following thread
Discussion 22463 -
it is said that even a mother who has feed her children will not have any concern about her favorites to that day! secondly how much good deeds a person can do in his life that he or she could save others….this power is only given to prophets & they have rights for saving others & they will do it IA.
-
Abase 33-37
اِس لیے جب وہ کانوں کو بہرا کر دینے والی آجائے گی تو اِن سے پوچھو کہ پھر کدھر جائیں [48] گے؟اُس دن آدمی اپنے بھائی سے بھاگے گا،اور اپنی ماں سے، اپنے باپ سے،اپنی بیوی اور اپنے بیٹوں سے بھاگے گا۔اُس دن ہر شخص کو اِن میں سے اپنی اپنی پڑی ہوگی۔
-
There is no concept of claiming anyone’s bad deeds as a mean to adjust against one’s good deeds. This goes against the very notion of Justice. Quran has also clarified this:
اَلَّا تَزِرُ وَازِرَۃٌ وِّزۡرَ اُخۡرٰی.وَ اَنۡ لَّیۡسَ لِلۡاِنۡسَانِ اِلَّا مَا سَعٰی.وَ اَنَّ سَعۡیَہٗ سَوۡفَ یُرٰی.ثُمَّ یُجۡزٰىہُ الۡجَزَآءَ الۡاَوۡفٰی.(53: 38-41)
That no soul shall bear another’s burden and that [in the Hereafter] a man shall only receive that which he strove [for in this world] and that what he has earned shall soon be shown to him; he shall then be fully rewarded. (53:38-41)
Even Prophets do not have an absolute power of intercession, their intercession is subject to God’s will after it has been decided that the person under consideration deserves forgiveness after application of principles of Justice, it is only after that intercession will come into play. For details on intercession, you can refer to the following thread:
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
