-
Status Of Hadith By Umm-e-Salma On Parda In Relation To A Blind Sahabi
I was listening to ghamidi sb in response to 23 questions and topic was parda. Ghambi sb said that before presenting riwayat we should read critical analysis by muhadiseen. I would like to from which books and from which authors i can read those analysis??
-
5 Replies
-
Status Of Hadith By Umm-e-Salma On Parda In Relation To A Blind Sahabi
updated 2 years, 10 months ago
2 Members
·
5
Replies
-
It is a very detailed and technical science of the narrators of Hadith. These are voluminous books. Like
Taqreeb Al Tehze
Tehzeeb Al Tehzeeb
Siar Alaam Al Nubla
Etc
-
I just want to know reference of those hadis, claimed as zaheef by ghamdi sb in lecture regarding perdah… I can write those if you want me so
-
Yes please
-
Bibi um e salma se riwayat jjis me ek nabeena sahabi k saamne RasoolullAllah SAW ne fermaya agar wo(sahabi) nhe dekh sakta lakin ap to dekh sakti ho…
-
This Hadith has been recorded by Musnad Ahmad 26537, Sunan Abu Dawood 4112, Sunan Tirmizi 2778.
You can see in their explanationatory notes by the Muhadditheen that this Hadith is weak due to he first narrator Nabhaan who is unknown. Moreover this Hadith is against the authentic Hadith of Fatima bint Qais who was asked by the prophet to spend her waiting period after her divorce in the house of Ibn Umme Maktoom because he was blind and it she could remove her garments without the fear that he might see her.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
