-
Breastfeeding Adults
https://sunnah.com/nasai/26/126
This hadith seems to be used by non Muslims against Islam. What does it mean? Is this allowed?
-
15 Replies
-
Breastfeeding Adults
updated 4 years, 3 months ago
5 Members
·
15
Replies
-
This hadith uses the specific word suckle
https://quranx.com/Hadith/Muslim/USC-MSA/Book-8/Hadith-3425/
-
These may not be the exact words of prophet SAW. There are lots of changes that happen to narrations as it gets transmitted from one person to another.
-
But the question is then does drinking the milk of a woman make someone haraam from someone else? If this a ruling why is it not mentioned anywhere (to my knowledge)? Because the person that drank the milk was not a child
-
Please refer to the video below 36:21 to 50:30
Relationship by fosterage has been covered in detail along with Ghamidi Sahab’s perpective on the above mentioned incident of Abu Hudhaifah & Salim.
-
The traditional narrative suggests it was one time exception for Salim (adult) only w/ some sort of cup over 4 or 5 days. It is also suggested all wives of the Prophet (AS) except Ayesha (RA) considered it to be an exception made for Salim.
I haven’t researched this topic much. The videos posted above deal with a similar yet different issue (not adult).
-
Alhamdullilah the video Umer bhai Sekt talks about it being an exception as they adopted the son before the ayah of surah Ahzaab so this was to be taken as an exception to the rule
-
Good to know. What is the timestamp in the video?
-
-
36:21 till end
-
Ghamidi sb’s interpretation and explanation is very convincing but then i came across this article and im utterly confused.
-
Which point in specific is causing the confusion?
If you’ve understood the principles of how we approach the religion then it shouldn’t cause any confusion.
-
You’re right. Thank you for this necessary and essential reminder. JazakAllah bhai.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
