-
Homosexuality In Quran And Punishment For This Act?
I question came about homosexuality
Quran doesn’t say homosexuality is forbidden for Muslims. It mentioned it in context with previous nation of Lut AS but never said anything about it being forbidden for muslims.
Similarly it mentions how Zina is forbidden explicitly. It doesn’t deal with homosexuality same way, why?
What is the Hadd of homosexuality? Ibn Hazam says it’s only 10 whips.
Please clarify
Thanks
-
6 Replies
-
Homosexuality In Quran And Punishment For This Act?
updated 2 years, 8 months ago
3 Members
·
6
Replies
-
In my opinion, Allah’s basic laws and rules don’t change over time. All stories in Quran are to explain Allah laws.
The question about how serious is the sin of homosexuality, I would guess it is quite serious, but not to the level of unforgiveable or to the level of Shirk. But if someone knowingly continues without repenting, asking Allah for forgiveness and not striving to stop, then it would get more serious. Remember Allah destroyed communities because they were cheating people in commerce in terms of weight and measure and Allah also destroyed communities based on homosexuality.
-
I my opinion Zina is more serious than homosexuality because Zina destroys a marriage relationship, it damages the life of children born out of wedlock and it destroys the wider community, but ultimately it is Allah who would decide on the seriousness of each sin based on all circumstances and variables. We can’t decide.
-
-
I agree with u brother and that’s how I understood it too
But Quran mentioned big crimes and then mentioned it explicitly like Zina, murder, honesty in trade. Quran mentioned these sins by other nations but also asked Muslims not to do it
Homosexuality is the same but it’s not explicitly forbidden.
I do not have an issue with rational arguments, it actually highlights the problem even more that why Quran didn’t address it clearly
-
Regarding Homosexuality in Quran, please see::
Discussion 66225 • Reply 66258
Regarding punishment of Homosexuality, please refer to the video below from 31:41 to 32:54
-
Umer bhai thanks for the answer
Is the whole video is about homosexuality? I’ll watch it insha Allah
I respectfully disagree that homosexuality can be included in Fawahish. Fawahish is with respect to others
Homosexuality means one is attracted to another person of same sex. He/she can marry him/her. It’s limited to that one person just like in marriage.
There r no boundaries crossed if society accepts homosexuality as normal variant of human behavior
-
Brother Umer
I accept my mistake
Quran clearly mentions homosexuality as Fawahish in 7:80, I missed it
Thanks for your help
-
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
