Ask Ghamidi

A Community Driven Discussion Portal
To Ask, Answer, Share And Learn

Forums Forums Sources of Islam 14. Qanoon E Itmam E Hujjat (Law Of Divine Punishment) – 23 Questions Series

  • 14. Qanoon E Itmam E Hujjat (Law Of Divine Punishment) – 23 Questions Series

    Posted by Ahsan on April 2, 2022 at 5:24 am

    Part 1 – Episode 72

    00:34- Objection on Ghamidi sb view about Itmam-e-Hujjat

    1:47- What is the foundation of your stance on Itmam-Hujjat?

    28:53- Mission of Prohepts wrt Surah nisa verse 163-165

    33:34- Ibne Kathir view on Surah nisa verse 163-165

    36:12- Summary of discussion

    Link to Hadith Project for Itmam Hujjah:
    1) Link 1

    2) Link 2

    3) Link 3

    Ahsan replied 1 year, 11 months ago 1 Member · 20 Replies
  • 20 Replies
  • 14. Qanoon E Itmam E Hujjat (Law Of Divine Punishment) – 23 Questions Series

    Ahsan updated 1 year, 11 months ago 1 Member · 20 Replies
  • Ahsan

    Moderator April 2, 2022 at 5:26 am

    Part 2 – Episode 73

    00:00- Intro

    1:20- Is concept of Itmam – Hujjat mentioned in Quran?

    15:20- Law of itmam hujjat as mentioned in Surah Yunus verses 45-54

    25:09- Comments by Mu’tazilite scholar Zamakshi on these verses

    29:12- Comments by Ahle Sunnah scholar Qadi Baydawi on these verses

    31:57- Comments by Ahle Sunnah scholar Abu Hayyan al-Gharnati on these verses

    42:00- Overview of Surah Yunus verses 45-54

  • Ahsan

    Moderator April 2, 2022 at 5:27 am

    Part 3 – Episode 74

    00:00- Summary of last episode

    1:21- What are the details of this practice against previous nation?

    6:10- Comment on Surah Araf verse 94-96

    13:26- Comment on Surah Ibrahim verses 9-14

    22:44- Early scholar opinion on this verse

    25:20- Comment on Surah Qasas 58-59

    27:13- Comment on Surah Saffat verse 171-179

    29:30- Comment on Surah Bani Israel verse 77

    30:20- Comment on Surah Mujaddlah verses 20-21

    33:28- Comment on Surah Qamar verses 1-45

  • Ahsan

    Moderator April 2, 2022 at 5:27 am

    Part 4 – Episode 75

    00:30- Summary of last episode

    2:14- How itmam-e-hujjat is done?

    4:42- Comment on an excerpt from maqamat chp-43 about how its done.

    9:00- Comment on surah hijjar verse 1-8

    14:51- Comment on surah tauba verse 70

    17:00- what do messenger do during this period?

    21:56- Comment on surah Haaqqah verse 1-37

    29:30- Do prophets go door to door to warn? in light of verse 58-59

  • Ahsan

    Moderator April 2, 2022 at 5:28 am

    Part 5 – Episode 76

    00:00- summary of last episode

    1:30- How punishment happens? Comment on surah Yunus verse 46, Raad-40, Gaffir-77

    8:58- Comment on surah Zukhruf verse 40-42

    13:00- Comments of suddi and tabbari on these verses

    19:30- How punishment happens in context of surah tauba verse 52

    24:04- Comments of Zamikshri and imam Raazi

    29:21- what is divine punishment in context of surah zumer verse 25-26

    31:30- Comment on surah mujadilah verse 20-21

    35:00- The wisdom behind the applicability of this law by different methods?

  • Ahsan

    Moderator April 2, 2022 at 5:28 am

    Part 6 – Episode 77

    00:00- Intro

    1:01- What is history for application of this law of divine punishment?

    6:02- Comment on Surah Hud verse 25-109

    32:05– Comment on Surah Aale imran verse 48 and onwards

    38:52- Comment on Gospel of matthew Chapter 24 verse 32-41

    41:04- Comment on Surah Bani israel verse 3-7

    46:09- Excerpt from Tafhim ul quran

  • Ahsan

    Moderator April 2, 2022 at 5:29 am

    Part 7 – Episode 78

    00:00- Summary

    01:35- What does Quran tells us about itmam e Hujjat by Prophet Mohammad saww and historical context?

    14:00- Comments on Surah nisa verse 97 and onwards

    18:15- Comments on Surah Nahl verse 106-109

    26:00- In context of Guzwa e Badar

    28:30- In context of sulah hudaiba

    32:32- Background of extension of Prophetic mission

  • Ahsan

    Moderator April 2, 2022 at 5:29 am

    Part 8 – Episode 79

    00-00: Intro and summary of last episode

    5:11- Different roles of Prophets and extension of Prophetic mission

    9:51- Different aspect of Prophethood of Hazrat Mohammad saww

    13:26- Aspects of applicability of divine punishment

    16:50- Itmam e hujja for Ahle Kitab and reasons of accord between different tribes

    27:15- Wisdom behind defensive wars

    28:50- Wisdom behind testing believers

    31:15- Capital Punishment to unbelievers with enemity to Islam

    35:50- Why punishment given by hand of muslims?

    39:05- Comments on Guzwa Bader in context of Surah Anfaal

  • Ahsan

    Moderator April 2, 2022 at 5:30 am

    Part 9 – Episode 80

    00:00- Summary of previous episode

    1:44- How Badar is divine punishment on Kuffar? Back ground and reality of history

    16:36- Comment on Surah Anfal verse 11 and onwards

    33:48- Difference between normal battle vs Badar battle

    36:37- Comments on Abu Lahab in coxtext of Surah Lahab

  • Ahsan

    Moderator April 2, 2022 at 5:30 am

    Part 10 – Episode 81

    00:00- Intro

    1:23- The 3 strategies of Allah during the interval of respite

    5:02- 1st Strategy in the light of Surah Mohammad verse 4-6

    10:11- 2nd strategy in the light of Surah Baqarah verse 190-193

    17:09- 3rd strategy in the light of Surah Baqarah verse 155-157

    22:35- Why Muslims were defeated at Uhud in the light of Surah Al-Imran verse 137-143, 152-153 and 179

    31:04- Battle of Ahzab, an excerpt from Tafheem Ul Quran

    37:20- Aftermath

  • Ahsan

    Moderator April 2, 2022 at 5:30 am

    Part 11 – Episode 82

    00:00- Summary

    1:26- Aftereffects of Battle of Ahzab (Trench). 5th Hijri, Muslims intention to do Umrah

    8:57- Accord of Hudaibiya in the light of Surah Fath verse 22-25

    14:09- How Accord of Hudaibiya was a Great vicotry according to Tafheem Ul Quran

    23:04- The completion of time of repsite in light of Surah Tauba/Azaab

    28:22- The breach of accord of Hudaibiya and after effects by Quraish according to Tafheem Ul Quran

    34:21- Announcement of Divine punishment in light of Surah Tauba/Azaab

  • Ahsan

    Moderator April 2, 2022 at 5:31 am

    Part 12 – Episode 83

    00:00-Summary of past discussion

    3:00- Introduction to invitation of Islam to People of book

    8:12- Treaty of Yathrib with jews form Seerat-e- Ibne Hisham

    14:20- What is the wisdome behind the treaty?

    15:10- The breach of treaty by Jews as discussed by Molana Modadi in Surah Hashr exgesis

    26:38- First era of anomisity of Jews against Muslims, Baina Qanuqa Tribe

    32:05- Breach of Treaty by Bani Nazeer

    37:16- Breach of Treaty by Banu Quraiza

    46:00- Discussion of Letters sent by Prophet Mohammad saw

  • Ahsan

    Moderator April 2, 2022 at 5:31 am

    Part 13 – Episode 84

    00:00- summary of last episode

    11:18- Itmam e Hujjah upon various kingdoms an excerept of Tafhim ul Quran

    23:19 – Divine decree by Allah in surah Tauba verse 29

    28:01- Tafsir of surah Tauba verses by Ibn Kathir

    33:09- The target group of surah Tauba verses 29.

  • Ahsan

    Moderator April 2, 2022 at 5:32 am

    Part 14 – Episode 85

    00:00- Summary of previous episodes

    2:46- Divine decree for hypocrites wrt to Surah Tauba verses 83-87

    8:00- Divine decree to Reward for believers wrt to Surah Noor ayah 55

    11:58- Why there was difference in divine decree between people of books and mushriks?

    17:51- God has denounced the justification of shirk in Surah Zumar then why it cannot be applied to current muslims?

    19:38- Treatment of hypocrites

    20:40- Implementation of divine decree for people of book wrt an excerpt from Tafheem ul Quran

    33:00- The responsiblity of Sahaba to implement divine punishment

  • Ahsan

    Moderator April 2, 2022 at 5:32 am

    Part 15 – Episode 86

    00:00- Summary of last episode

    5:32- Comments on Sahaba to implement divine punishment wrt Sahih Bukhari Hadith #3159(https://sunnah.com/bukhari:3159)

    31:06- Comments on Musand e Abd bin Humaid Hadith # 545

    34:54- Comments on Sahih muslim Hadith # 5113

    40:35- Comments on ibne Abi shiba Hadith # 18833

    47:06- Comments on Sahih Bukhari Hadith # 25 https://sunnah.com/bukhari:25

    Link to Hadith Project regarding itmam e hujjah

    https://www.javedahmedghamidi.org/#!/hadith/5adb733db7dd1138372db96f?articleId=5adb7442b7dd1138372dd6bf

    https://www.javedahmedghamidi.org/#!/hadith/5adb7357b7dd1138372dbd60?articleId=5adb7442b7dd1138372dd6c9

    https://www.javedahmedghamidi.org/#!/hadith/5adb7368b7dd1138372dbf90?articleId=5adb7443b7dd1138372dd6d8


  • Ahsan

    Moderator April 10, 2022 at 12:57 pm

    Part 16 – Episode 87

    00:00- Summary of previous episodes

    2:21- Difference between Rasool and nabi

    7:13- Difference between Rasool and nabi according to Quran verse Surah Hajj verse 52

    8:17- Zamakhsri explantion of Surah Hajj verse 52.

    9:02- Traditional view about difference in Rasool and Nabi

    20:22- Why scholars couldnt differentiate according to Quran

    21:22- How rasool definition impacts your understanding of Quran.

    25:16- Impact of itmam hujjah on understading of Qital

    36:48- Qital wrt to Surah Mohammad verse 4

    42:55- Qital wrt to Surah hujrat verse 9-10

    48:02- Qital wrt to Surah Baqarah verse 193

    52:40- Solution to Dominance of Islam vs Religion of Peace

  • Ahsan

    Moderator April 24, 2022 at 3:02 am

    Part 17 – Episode 88

    00:00- Summary of last episode

    2:10- Relation with Yadood o Nisara and Hanood

    9:18- Comments on Surah mumtehena verses 1-10

    23:10- Comments on Surah mumtehena verses 57-60

    26:05- Comments on Surah Ale Imran verses 113-120

    30:45- Is it possible to convey messageof Islam to people who are considered enemy?

    32:05- Commentts on degoratory behavoiur to kuffars

    34:19- Can we do Maghfirat prayers for non muslims wrt Surah Tauba verse 113-114?

  • Ahsan

    Moderator April 24, 2022 at 3:02 am

    Part 18 – Episode 89

    00:00- Summary of previous episodes and preface to understanding of hadith and impact of concept of itmam hujjah on it.

    21:19- Understanding of Shahih Bukhari Hadith # 3017 (https://sunnah.com/bukhari:3017)

    34:05- Law of Qisas according to Surah Baqarah verse #179. Its implication in modern state?

    44:15- Understanding of law of qisas according to tirmidi chapter any muslim cannot be killed in lieu of non muslim (https://sunnah.com/tirmidhi:1412, /tirmidhi/16)

    51:36- Law of inheritance in Surah nisa verse 11 and its applicability

    58:34- Understanding of law of inheritance according to Sahih Bukhari Hadith # 6764 (https://sunnah.com/bukhari:6764)

  • Ahsan

    Moderator May 14, 2022 at 1:16 am

    Part 19 – Episode 90

    00:00- Overview of previous episodes

    1:43- Why we cannot say that punishment was given due to some crimes but not shirk? Response from Surah Qamar verse 9 and onward

    24:32- What if some one say surah qamar is ijmal?

    29:26- Isn’t the punishment of Quresh was due to fisad fil ard?

    36:22- Can Ahle Kitab mean the people who didn’t breach the contract? Why the punishment different for Ahle-Kitab?

    40:17- The prophetic narration ask people to give the same option which were meant for Ahle Kitab

  • Ahsan

    Moderator May 14, 2022 at 1:16 am

    Part 20 – Episode 91

    00:00- Recap

    1:14- Original crime is Shirk then why there is difference in punishment?

    10:18- If Quran tells us that Ahle kitab were mushrik then why they are not called mushrikeen?

    15:21- what is the wisdom behind God calling them mushrik?

    17:30- Why there is difference in duration of respite for different nations?

    19:44- Is Nation of Hazrat Yunus was only nation who were forgiven?

    27:17- Why death punishment was not given to Bani Israel for doing shirk openly?

    30:05- Is there any realtion between law of itmam hujjat with punishment of Bani Israel till day of Judgment?

    https://youtu.be/ob5g-GDCfA8

  • Ahsan

    Moderator May 14, 2022 at 1:17 am

    Part 21 – Episode 92

    00:00- Recap

    1:14- Where did you conclude that days of 40 respite for nation of Hazrat Yunus?

    4:55- Was there any torment against Hazrat Ibrahim? if it didnt not happen to nation of Hazrat Ibrahim then how this law is true?

    9:27- Why there are two prophet at same time at same place (Hazrat Ibrahim and Hazrat Loot)?

    12:15- What happened to the nation of Egypt?

    14:24- Why mushrik were chose to punish Bani Israel?

    17:36- The war was due to rebellion in roman empire then how it is law of punishment?

    18:40- It is also said that followers of Hazrat isa were killed why it happened?

    19:35- Is the crime of killing prophet is not a big crime for divine punishment?

    23:43- Why respite was given when divine punishment was already decided?

    25:34- After divine punishment, kuffars believing is of no use. explain it?

    28:15- How itmam hujjah will happen in 40 days when it didn’t happened in 23 years?

    29:50- If letter is itmam hujjah what if they are not authentic?

    31:47- Why Shahba conquered different areas such Armenia etc?

    33:40- According Sahih Muslim hadith # 2842, Muslim will keep fighting till end of the day. How can u explain it?

    35:26- Can be Pusnishment of apostasy be equivalent to rebellion?

    37:36- Concluding Remarks and advise

    https://youtu.be/GhbLv0QPwqA

The discussion "14. Qanoon E Itmam E Hujjat (Law Of Divine Punishment) – 23 Questions Series" is closed to new replies.

Start of Discussion
0 of 0 replies June 2018
Now