-
Different Understanding Regarding Salah And Its Meaning Among Different Scholars
Sorry I lost the post, I had started, this is my reply to the moderator’s reply.
No, I don’t know of any sect that does not believe in namaz, but I do know of a point of view like Ghulam Pervaizi sahab and a person in my family’s circle who does not believe that namaz, roza and other ibadat exists. He has come to this understanding after studying quran, and he has a circle of like-minded people with him who believe the same. They discuss & study quran every week. I myself do not believe that ibadat does not exist. My journey of studying deen was partially inspired from his journey, because when he told me that namaz does not exists, something I had believed all my life exists, this perspective deeply confused me. So, I embarked on a journey to better my understanding of the deen. In the course of my search, I stumbled upon Ghamidi sahab’s narrative, and whatever I have heard, so far, makes sense to me and clarifies my perspective. Also, I had a lot of other questions which also have been answered by Ghamidi sahab’s narrative.
However, that person gave me a translation of the quran which I am attaching here, this describes salah in a different way. I did not find it convincing, but I would appreciate it if someone can elaborate it or a program or video can be done to elaborate on this for people like me who are suffering from the same confusion. Like I said my confusion has cleared after listening to Ghamidi sahab’s perspective, but still these things bother me somewhat, I am still in search of complete dil ki taskeen, so I would appreciate it if somebody can further clarify this.
Also, he provided me with a different version of the history which I am also attaching.
I would appreciate it if someone can shed some light on both documents.
Thank you so much for your time and consideration.
-
1 Reply
-
Different Understanding Regarding Salah And Its Meaning Among Different Scholars
updated 2 years, 8 months ago
2 Members
·
1
Reply
-
Following thread and given videos in it will be helpful in this context if you haven’t gone through them already:
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
