-
An Old Video
As far as I can remember Ghamidi sahab once said (in an old video) that Ashraf Ali Thaanvi sahab levelled an allegation of kufr on Imam Hameed uddin Farahi. When informed it farahi sahab said something like “he doesn’t know me” or something like that. Was it Ashraf Ali Thanvi or someone else ? I can’t correctly remember.
-
13 Replies
-
An Old Video
updated 2 years, 5 months ago
3 Members
·
13
Replies
-
Yes, it was Ashraf Ali Thanwi Sahab.
-
Yes it was Ashaf Ali Thanawi sahib and later, he took his Fatwa back.
-
Can you please provide the reference about the information of Ashraf Ali sahab taking the fatwa back ?
I did not know that.
-
-
To best of my memory the whole incident is narrated by Abdul Majid Daryabadi in his book Hakeemul Ummat Naqoosh o Tasuraat. It is available on line. But difficult to sift through to find the reference. However it is confirmed that Thanawi sahib reversed his fatwa.
-
Thank you very much. I read about his fatwa, in “hakeemul ummat”. I did not know that the same contains the fatwa being taken back.
-
-
-
bohot shukria bhy. Isi ki baat kar raha tha !! 🙂🙂🙂🙂🙂
-
According to Maolana Abdul Maajid, that incident took place AFTER Hameeduddin’s (R.A.) death. Ghamidi sahab says he was alive at that time. I request that someone raise this question to Ghamidi sahab in the Q&A session.
-
Please register for the next AG live event and ask this question personally.
-
Aap ka bohot shukria ji, umar sahab, aap ne mera sawal pohcha dia Ghamidi sahab ke paas.
May Inshallah Tafheemaat check karoonga. May ne maolana Maodoodi ki Tafheemul Quran Padhi hui hay. May nahi jaanta tha ke “Tafheemaat” naam ki ek aor kitaab bhi hay. Agar kisi ko us mazmoon ka reference miley to darkhwaast hay ke is Naacheez ko bhi muttalla’ kar deejiye.
Any ways bohot shukria ji aap hazraat ka.
-
can you please provide the reference so that i may check it too.
-
I downloaded a pdf of hakim ul ummat from the net. The page no. differ depending on the edition. In that edition it is on page 417 to 418 and probably further on as well, when Maolana abdul maajid discusses it with maolana ashraf ali sahab as to how he was influenced by shibli and farahi, and that he was not satisfied with the explanations that Ashraf sahab was giving for his fatwa…
-
-
Thanks It was there as you referred. Yes you are right, according to Daryabadi, it happened after the demise of Mawlana Farahi. We need to clarify it by Ghamidi sahab.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
