-
Renting A Goat For Mating Purposes
I am a little farm owner.i have a breeder male goat which we used for mating out goats and as well as other people’s goats and charged them 2k because the expense of feed and other thing are pretty much high my question is Is it permissible to take money for mating from a goat?
I have seen hadith of tiramzi in which it is not permissible but if i don’t charged them then it is more expensive to have breeder
Guide me about it
-
10 Replies
-
Renting A Goat For Mating Purposes
updated 1 year, 6 months ago
3 Members
·
10
Replies
-
provide complete reference or hadith
-
سنن الترمذي ت شاكر (3/ 564 و 565)
-
Can you give link to haith coz i couldn’t find the reference. it will b great if u can find here https://sunnah.com
-
-
Hadees no 1273
I found fatwa of some scholar in which this hadees is mentioned.
-
In this hadith https://sunnah.com/tirmidhi:1273 and https://sunnah.com/tirmidhi:1274,
first of all, it mention about horse. secondly, if you read complete hadith in both of them, it has been allowed for the purpose you mentioned.
According to Farahi school, Hadith should be understood in proper ay. Chk this thread for the principles of understanding hadith. Discussion 56230According to my understating, it is prohibited in hadith to avoid impurity. but I ill request @Irfan76 sb can give his scholarly opinion.
-
Is it allowed or not can u brief?
-
I think its ok but to be sure let wait for Irfan sb reply
-
-
Ok then we will wait
-
Every prohibition has a reason for prohibition and that is something immoral or unethical. In Ahadith, the narrators most of the time do not mention the reason or context and tell only the incident. The reason behind this prohibition seems to be uncertainty whether it will give pregnancy or not. This might have caused a conflict.
But if both parties are agreed, then there is no problem for charging a fee for the service provided.
Moreover, special breeds are reared to get better offspring, and it costs, so there is nothing unethical in it. You can charge for the mating of your male goat.
There are other certain things that were prohibited in the time of the prophet for reasons which no longer exist now, and that is why they are allowed.
-
Thank you sir well briefed
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
