Beard As Sunnah Of Prophet Ibrahim SWS
Hello there my question is regarding Sunnah and the understanding of beard, i saw a video on YouTube from a channel, in which a man criticized ghamidi sahab’s stance on beard and presented some points and mentioning 2 of them here.
1) he said something like ghamidi sahab in his book Meezan used the references of the book “Mufassil” by Dr Javad Ali, to enlist the Sunnah e Ibrahim. But in the same book of Mufassil, it is also mentioned that Beard is also a Sunnah e Ibrahim. So if what they said and how they presented it is right, then why did Ghamidi Sahab did not include it in list etc.
2) As we say that Sunnah is transfered to us from Prophet Muhammad through Ijma and tawattur, and we can see this ijma and tawattur in books of fiqh of old times and establish the ruling of anything that is coming from Ijma. But how do we establish the same ijma that goes back to Hazrat Ibrahim, as they are Sunnah e Ibrahim? + And if we say that those Sunnah of Hazrat Ibrahim from him to Hazrat Muhammad, were also transmitted without ijma and tawattur, in a similar manner like Ahadith and after Hazrat Muhammad it became Ijma, then what stops us from thinking that even in our time, hadith is also a source of Ijma. And if it’s Ijma then again, What are the resources to establish that Ijma?
Sentences after ‘+’ are my own.
In the last 870 days, 5,089 registered users have posted 40,654 messages under 9,722 unique topics on Ask Ghamidi.