-
Meat Of Ahle Kitab Halal?
There’s a ayah in the Qur’an that says” و طعام الذين اوتو “الكتاب حل لكم و طعامكم حل لهم almaaidah verse 5
The food of the Jews and Christians is halal for muslims and the food of the muslims is halal for the jews and Christians.
Also there’s a sahih hadeeth that says that Muhammad sallallahu alai hi wa sallam ate from the meat which a jewish lady prepared for him( obviously meat of the ahle Kitab). Discussions on this please
-
7 Replies
-
Meat Of Ahle Kitab Halal?
updated 4 years, 6 months ago
3 Members
·
7
Replies
-
This might be related.
-
I have heard the above question and answer session before too. So I know the veiw of janab Ghamidi saheb( I respect him a lot. May Allah grant him a healthy long life) I still would like to know what this ayah means and the hadeeth I mentioned. He didn’t explain it
-
As per Ghamidi sb, this ayah means that halal things on their table is halal for you. If they have alcohol or pork then it remains Haram, for e.g.
-
If it is halal things on their table, why specifically ahle Kitab? Can’t we eat halal things from any table?
-
-
JazakaAllahu khair, Be. Farhan Saiyed! What about the hadeeth where Muhammad sallallahu alai hi wa sallam ate from the meat of the jewish woman who poisoned the meat. He accepted her invitation without inquiring if the meat is zabiha or not because she’s from ahle Kitab?
-
Ghamidi sahab would argue that it was understood that they took God’s name before slaughtering, even though not mentioned in the hadith.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
