Ask Ghamidi

A Community Driven Discussion Portal
To Ask, Answer, Share And Learn

Forums Forums Sources of Islam 16. Meezan And Furqan ( میزان اور فرقان ) – Response To 23 Questions

Tagged: , ,

  • 16. Meezan And Furqan ( میزان اور فرقان ) – Response To 23 Questions

    Posted by Ahsan on December 3, 2022 at 3:32 pm

    Episode 1- Part 108

    00:00- Introduction, a criticism on Ghamidi sb stance of Quran as Meezan and Furqan

    4:44- Purpose of sending prophet and books according to surah Baqarah verse # 213

    27:50- Purpose of Quran according to Surah Al-Furqan verse # 1

    28:53- Comments of ibn e Kathir on Surah Al-Furqan verse # 1

    33: 23- If all books are Furqan, then which book will be followed in case of difference according to Surah Al-Maida verse # 48.

    38: 28- Comments of ibn e Kathir and ibn jalil on Surah Al-Maida verse# 48.

    Ahsan replied 1 year, 3 months ago 1 Member · 6 Replies
  • 6 Replies
  • 16. Meezan And Furqan ( میزان اور فرقان ) – Response To 23 Questions

    Ahsan updated 1 year, 3 months ago 1 Member · 6 Replies
  • Ahsan

    Moderator December 13, 2022 at 12:08 pm

    Episode 2- Part 109

    00:00- Recap of the previous episode

    4: 34- Background of surah Hadid verse # 25

    8:43- Comments on surah Hadid verse #25

    14:48- Background of surah shura verse # 13-18

    18: 34- Comments on surah shura verse # 13-18

    25:03- Comments on an excerpt from book Meezan

    https://www.javedahmedghamidi.org/#!/mizan/5aa6a4315e891e8f44a45788?chapterNo=0&subChapterNo=0&subChsecNo=3&lang=ur

  • Ahsan

    Moderator December 18, 2022 at 11:00 am

    Episode 3- Part 110

    00:00- Criticism at Ghamidi sb understanding of meaning of و in surah Baqarah verse # 213, Meezan use in Quran don’t refer to Quran, Ulema and lughat expert don’t take that meaning. How can you take it?

    3:35- Response to Criticism on Ghamidi sb understanding of surah Hadid verse # 25 and use of word meezan.

    16:30- Refutation of opinion of Ulema’s understanding of Meezan

    24:23- Explanation of context of surah Hadid verse #25 and surah shura verse # 13-18

  • Ahsan

    Moderator December 24, 2022 at 7:59 am

    Episode 4- Part 111

    00:00- Summary of previous episodes

    00:55- Preface to response to criticism on Ghamidi sb understanding of و

    5:35- An excerpt from Ibne hisham’s book about و

    11:46- How Sarf o nav started?

    13:43- response to criticism of Ghamidi sb understanding of و

    19:26- Are, the explanation of و by scholar, conditions or the way of using it?

    24:25- Example of translation of و from zamkashi exegesis with reference to surah maida verse # 15

    28:44- Understanding of و from Surah Baqarah verse # 53

  • Ahsan

    Moderator December 31, 2022 at 10:43 am

    Episode 5- Part 112

    00:00-Recap of previous episode.

    1:25- Why you didnt give reference of zamakshi in the meaning of و?

    5:20- Why Zamkashi didnt accept Quran is meezan in tafsir of baqarah verse?

    6:35- Is Quran meezan and furqan for matters other than deen?

    8:45- Why Quran donot guide to truth of historical events?

    10:25- Why we cannot verify principles of understanding of Quran from Quran?

    13:39- If there is confusion in understanding of Quranic word, what Quran does for it?

    16:32- Solution to the problem of interest according to Quran?

    18:15- If something is established before, will it be a meezan o furqan?

    20:10- You consider Sunnat as furqan, then what is status of Quran?

    24:37- Solution to problem of rafai yaden according to Quran?

    28:05- Solution to problem of zakat according to Quran?

    29:36- Isnt it true Quran is only furqan to belief?

  • Ahsan

    Moderator January 6, 2023 at 8:21 am

    Episode 6- Part 113

    00:40- Your school of thought does not practically consider Quran as meezan. For instance, The coherence in Quran is forced upon Quran

    8:27- If someone rejects your understanding of coherence then will he present his theory of coherence?

    12:19- Why we couldn’t ingrain our minds to appreciate the Quranic writing style?

    20:10- Didn’t scholars of the past also infer itmam e hujjah concept in their tafsir?

    22:13- If we ignore the coherence of the Quran, will it affect the communication of the Quran?

    24:11- Isn’t it a contradiction when you called Quran and Sunnat as meezan?

    27:56- Quran assert that the previous book was meezan, but these books have gone through many changes.

  • Ahsan

    Moderator January 13, 2023 at 11:01 am

    Episode 7- Part 114

    0:28- Farahi school scholar claims Quran is meezan and Furqan, and even Prophet cannot change its order. However, they change the meaning during interpretation.

    10:55- What is the matter of all animals in Noah’s Ark?

    16:04- How Prophet saw explain details of Quranic commands?

    18:00- Why did you understand Al Kitab as Quran?

    20:53- What is meant by the hadith which says God has given Prophet Quran and its complement?

    22:56- Why did scholars not mention Quran names as meezan or Furqan?

    24:55- Why you named your book meezan?

    25:26- Summarizing point of view?

The discussion "16. Meezan And Furqan ( میزان اور فرقان ) – Response To 23 Questions" is closed to new replies.

Start of Discussion
0 of 0 replies June 2018
Now