-
Which Scholar Should I Follow
AOA
agr 2 scholars k darmian ikhtalaf ho tu kis ko follow kya jay aur aik scholar kahy ye theek ha lakin majority scholars usko shirk karar dein koe choti bt nai shirk karar dein agr mamla ye ho k aisa krain gy tu ghalat ha ya gunah chota gunah ha ya bara gunah ha lakin shirk ki tu maafi nai ha
tu kis scholar ko follow kya jay jaisy sary scholars kehte hn eids k elawa sari celebration bidat hain wish krna aur join krna non Muslims festivals ko tu ye shirk ha lakin waha he Janab Ghamidi sb aur 1 2 aur scholars kehte hn ye jaiz ha tu kis ko follow krain kiun k insan agr unko follow krta ha tu deen aur life bht mushkil ho jati ha aur ya asani b lagti ha logic b waha b logic ha lakin though ha lakin wo isko shirk kehte hain kya phir ye soch kr k shirk se bacha jay tu bhtr ha safer side pe pehle scholars ka he opinion mana lya jay kya ye thek hoga kiun k is tarh wo Scholars mostly chezon ko kabira gunah batate shirk aur kufr btate hn jis se insan zaida sensitive hojty aisy ma kya kiya jay jaisy ma Janab Ghamidi ka opinion follow krna chahti hn aur wo muje zaida sensible intellectual lagte hn lakin yaha bt shirk ki ho tu kya krain wish krna chahte hn asani lana chahte hn deen ma duniya ma ta k achy sy follow kr skain lakin kahain apni asani b endr ajati ha apni wish b tu kya ye ghalat hoga
ma ye janna chahti hn kya ma sahi path pe hn agr Janab Ghamidi sahb k opinion ko follow krun
JAZAK ALLAH
-
8 Replies
-
Which Scholar Should I Follow
updated 1 year, 2 months ago
3 Members
·
8
Replies
-
پیروی سکالر کی نیہں، دلیل کی کرنی چاہیے۔ اختلافی معاملات میں دونوں طرف کے دلائل کا جائزہ لیں اور جو دلیل عقل اور ضمیر کو مطمئن کرے، اس کا اختیار کر لیں۔
ایک راے اختیار کرنے کے بعد معلوم ہو کہ راے درست نہیں تو حق کا تقاضا ہے اسے چھوڑ کر وہ راے اختیار کریں جو درست لگے
بالفرض آپ کی اختیار کردہ راے اصل میں غلط بھی ہو تو خدا کے نزدیک یہ مورد الزام نہیں بناتا۔
-
nahi sir ap farma rhy hn scholar ko follow krna zarori nai
lakin insan ha uski nature ha apne lye asani he chahti ha mushkil nai
lakin ulma kufr shirk karar dy dete agr kisi ne apni asani ko paishe nazar rkh kr b faisla krna ho wo majobor hojta ha phir kiun k dosron ne tu shirk aur kufr karar dy dya ha tu insan kahy ga safe ye he hai k inki bt he man lo is tarh tu unki he hamesha mani jay gi
dhondne pe muje ye jawabat mile
-
sir ap bhi is pe roshni dalye
ma Janab Ghamidi sb ki raye ko ikhtayar krna chahti hn us ma muje apne lye zaida asani mehsos hoti ha wrna kya ma har kisi ko kehti hn meri birthday celebrate na kro na ma celebrate nai krti ya ye mushreekana roots rkhta ha jb k daleel tu dono scholars dete hn apni apni side ki zahir ha un ki daleel zaida sahi lagy gi jo traditional scholars hn k shirk sy link ha iska is lye celebrate nai krna wish nai krna insan kahy bt b thek ha aur safe side b ha lakin agr apni wish ko made nazar rkhte hove is raye ko ikhtyr kya jay jo Ghamidi Sahb ka opinion ha tu ma sahi path pe hun kiun k insan khush rehna chahta hn celebrate krna chahta ha lakin dosre scholars ki btain k ye shirk ha ye kufr ha ap deen se bahr hn etc insan ghamidi sahab ka opinion apna b ly tu aik emotional torture rehta ha k kahain hum shirk ma shamil tu nai ho rhy kiun k dosre scholars k mutabiq tu Hazrat essa A.S ki wapsi ko na manana apne aqeede sy inkar ha wo isko aqeedy ka hisa karar dete hn wo kehte apka iman mukamal nai is tarh ki baton ma insan kry tu kya kry ye kehna asan ha ap unki he bt sunain ap dosra opinion apna lein traditional jaisy salon sy chalta arha lakin is sy mehsos hota deen tu bht tang ha koe khushi nai kuch nai mushkil ha deen sth ma ye ehsas b jari rehtaha k hum shirk tu nai kr rhy ya shamil tu nai ho rhy aisy ma kya krna chahye confusion waly answer tu har koe dy rha k mutmain nahi
rehnumai farma dijye
JAZAK ALLAH
-
Allah nai apko aqal ki naimat sai nawaza hai uska istemal karain aisay maamlat main.
Ghamidi Sahab ki raye agar sirf is wajah sai ikhteyar ki jaa rahi hai kai us main asani nazar aa rahi hai laikin apki aqal traditional view ko zayada sahih maan rahi hai, toh aap apnay saath khayanat kar rahi hain aisee surat main. Jiska istadlal apko qawi lagta hai, usay follow bh karna chaiyai. Agar aap dayant dari sai aik raye ikhteyar karain gi aur woh aslan ghalat samjhi gae hoo toh us surat main Allah kai han muakhza nhi hai.
-
-
Janab Ghamidi sahab ki bt sirf asani k lye nai man rhe daleel b sunti hn aur samjh b ati ha aur bht c btaon ki daleel kafi logical b bht. lakin agr kisi mamlea daleel agr dono tarf ki suni jay aur theek lagain dono he kiun dono sides bt daleel se he krti aur insan sirf is lye wo raye ikhtayr kry jis ma safe side ha kiun k ye shirk karar dy rhy hain lakin daleel pehle wale scholar ki b sahi lag rhe aur mozu mehsos ho rhe ha aur dosre ki b aisy ma kya jay sirf is lye k zaida safe side ha tu ikhtyar kr lya jay kiun k phir tu insan kahy ga bachna bhtr faisla ha phir tu insan har raye ma extreme wali raye he choose kry ga tu mamlat ma mushkil nai ho jay gi jb k deen tu fitrat pe mabni ha asan ha
agr aik he raye mazbot lagy lakin dosre ki b theek lagy lakin mazbot wali extreme pe ho aur dosri b apko thek lag rhe ha tu kya insaan asan raye ikhtyr kr skta ha
-
Ji bilkul asan wali raye ikhteyar ki jaa sakti hai bashrtay kai uski daleel sai insan agree karta hoo.
-
-
main bena daleel k nahi keh rhe k Janab Ghamidi sahab ki koe daleel nai suni aur koe daleel samj b nai aye phir b follow kya jay ma munasib aur zaida bhtr daleel ma aur extreme aur kuch thora bht asani wali raye k darmian poch rhe hn
-
JAZAK ALLAH
boht shukria Janab
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
