-
The Arrival Of Imam Mehdi(a.s)
The are many hadith’s on the arrival of Imam Mahdi (a.s) before the life after and it is also believed that he will Dajjal as well. What is the right belief on this whole matter?
-
7 Replies
-
The Arrival Of Imam Mehdi(a.s)
updated 3 years, 6 months ago
6 Members
·
7
Replies
-
Salam pls. see this thread: Discussion 4207
-
Javed Ahmad Ghamidi writes in his book Mizan:
Besides these, the coming of the Mahdi and that of Jesus from the heavens are also regarded as signs of the Day of Judgment. I have not mentioned them. The reason is that the narratives of the coming of the Mahdi do not conform to the standards of hadith criticism set forth by the muhaddithun. Some of them are weak and some fabricated; no doubt, some narratives, which are acceptable with regard to their chain of narration, inform us of the coming of a generous caliph; (Muslim, No: 7318) however, if they are deeply deliberated upon, it becomes evident that the caliph they refer to is Umar ibn Abd al-Aziz who was the last caliph from a Sunni standpoint. This prediction of the Prophet has thus materialized in his personality, word for word. One need not wait for any other Mahdi now.
Mr. Ghamidi has summed it up nicely. I also think that the idea of an Imam to appear before the end of days is a bit too far fetched and most likely a later fabrication.
-
Sir then what about Shia hadith on imam Mahdi?? And even thier are mutawwattir hadith on imam Mahdi
-
See this book by Immadi for Mahdi related narrations
-
-
Please also see:
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
