Ask Ghamidi

A Community Driven Discussion Portal
To Ask, Answer, Share And Learn

Forums Forums Youth and Islam Hacking Video Games In A Personal/Isolated Environment

  • Hacking Video Games In A Personal/Isolated Environment

    Posted by Abdul Sattar Ahmed on July 18, 2023 at 5:08 pm

    Question for anyone knowledgeable in software/ video game laws and Islam:-

    Context:- There is a legal memory editing software out there called cheat engine which you can attach to computer games and enhance player experience via editing memory values and changing the game speed (Slow motion/Fast motion). In a nutshell this software allows a player of the game to modify game data and speed such that one can enhance game experience and potentially get more freedom in the video game and have more fun and is hence cheating in the game.

    Potential problem/dilema:- vast majority of video games require people to comply with the EULA (end user licence agreement) which in almost all cases prohibits cheating in online and/or multiplayer mode which has the potential to ruin the experience of other players and thus directly or indirectly cause monetary damage to the production house which is hence copyright infringement and clearly wrong to do so.

    However there is still an online debate as to whether using softwares like Cheat Engine violates the EULA of the video game if you are cheating in offline single player mode such that it’s only for your own personal use and the experience of other players is not being effected and no monetary damage can be attributed to the production house.

    From my own research on various forums etc the majority of people argue that it is ethically fine to do so and it does not violate EULA to hack in single player offline mode as there is no proof of monetary damage to production house and no one is being harmed and along the lines that it is none of anyone’s business on how you choose to entertain yourself in this isolated environment. Even if there is something in the EULA that looks prohibitive to do so, it does not apply as monetary damage can’t be proved and it falls under fair use (using this logic, a company called Lewis Galoob toys won a lawsuit against Nintendo who sued them for copyright infringement but lost source:-,_Inc._v._Nintendo_of_America,_Inc.)

    However according to some other people and Chat GPT it is still considered a violation of EULA as it interferes with the intended game design and violates integrity of the game (does not make sense to me personally as I’m just having fun with a game I payed for and no one is being harmed 😕). But in this case, the production house will not enforce any breach of contact as there is no monetary done to them and also maybe as it’s hard for them to detect an activity of this nature done on a personal level.

    Question:- if I use Cheat Engine on single player games I’ve obtained legitimately just to enhance my own fun in a manner that does not amount to any “Haqtalafi” on face value (monetary loss/stealing from game developers/ruining the fair play and/or experience of players who I’m potentially playing with), is it a still a sin to do so even if I’m potentially violating the EULA but harming no one in the process?

    Abdul Sattar Ahmed replied 2 months ago 4 Members · 4 Replies
  • 4 Replies
  • Hacking Video Games In A Personal/Isolated Environment

    Abdul Sattar Ahmed updated 2 months ago 4 Members · 4 Replies
  • Ahsan

    Moderator July 18, 2023 at 11:32 pm

    If you bought the game and don’t spread it unlawfully then its ok to enhance your own experience in offline mode.
    Injustice scenario will be as follows

    1) if you unlawfully distribute it robbing them off their revenue.

    2) In case of online game, hacking the system will give you unfair advantage and potentially ruin the business.

    I will request @Irfan76 or @UmerQureshi sb to share their opinion too.

  • Dr. Irfan Shahzad

    Scholar July 19, 2023 at 3:16 am

    I agree with Mr Ahsan Jalal’s answer.

  • Saad Aamir

    Member July 19, 2023 at 2:14 pm

    I don’t think EULA has any legal standing. Even if you break it, it is not unlawful but most companies have a common practice which is, that they will simply ban your account if you do break their EULA including hacking/cheating in a single player game or modifying any of their products. This never happened but if they do, on an extremely rare chance, ban you, you will have to accept that and move on.

    I think everyone agrees that it is not a sin or illegal. It’s just doing something against company’s terms but they tolerate it as long as it doesn’t affect others but they have full power to not tolerate it.

  • Abdul Sattar Ahmed

    Member August 2, 2023 at 11:00 am

    Thanks for the answers 😊

You must be logged in to reply.
Login | Register