-
Hadith Books And Mutawatir Narrations
The question below is like showing lamp to the sun but asking out of curiousity and for clarity.
What is the authenticity of the narrations that ghamidi sir is narrating from the books like Tazkaratul huffaz and Al-Hadis wal Muhaddisoon ? Are they ahad or reached the status of tawattur ?
Jazakallahu Khairaa
-
4 Replies
-
Hadith Books And Mutawatir Narrations
updated 8 months, 2 weeks ago
3 Members
·
4
Replies
-
There are no mutawatir hadith narrations. For details please see:
-
What about the narrations of the biographies of hadith huffaz present in the books Tazkaratul huffaz and Al-Hadis wal Muhaddisoon. If they are also ahad narrations then how do we know about the authenticity of such biographical history ? Is there a sanad like sahih, hasan & dhaef for the biographical statements also ?
-
Following response (only the premise) will help you further understand Ghamidi Sahab’s perspective in this regard:
-
-
As explained in the article shared above, all narrations are ahad without any distinction. A lot of history, including biographical information is transmitted through ahad. It does not need to have strict standards of authenticity because of its secular nature.
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
