-
AL Zuhri Status In The Sight Of Ghamidi Sahab
Does Ghamidi Sb accept Hadith narrating from Imam Zuhri or not?
-
6 Replies
-
AL Zuhri Status In The Sight Of Ghamidi Sahab
updated 9 months, 3 weeks ago
4 Members
·
6
Replies
-
Ghamidi saheb accepts a hadith if it fulfills the criteria he has elaborated in his book and talks, no matter whether it is narrated by Zuhri, but merely the authority of Zuhri does not validate a hadith, especially when he is the sole authority of a narration.
-
Bro can you please elaborate the below mentioned point of yours;
“but merely the authority of Zuhri does not validate a hadith, especially when he is the sole authority of a narration.”
-
For comments of Ghamidi Sahab, please refer to the video below from 17:34 to 27:56
-
Watched the above video but there is a difference, Ghamidi Sb criticised the Zuhri based on his personal traits in narrating Hadith while on Imam Bukhari he is not criticising like that.
Ghamidi Sb is reporting the narrations of Imam Zuhri in his book Mizan, but when a person has serious deficiencies as per Hadith rules then what is the reason to quote hadiths from him?
Or Ghamidi Sb in his book Mizan has taken the Hadiths of Zuhri which are not narrating by him as a sole authority.
Pls clarify.
-
Ahadith from Zuhari are taken only when the foundation of a problem is already established and the hadith is not of the kind in which Zuhri’s reputation is not good.
In the framework of Ghamidi saheb, even weak hadith is accepted when the foundation of the problem is already established.
-
امام زہری کی ہر وہ روایت قبول کی جائے گی جس میں وہ منفرد نا ہو،
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
