-
View About Mirza Qadiani
What is the view of Ghamidi sahib about someone like Mirza ghulam ahmed qadiani, who believes that
1. Isa AS was not born without a father and Maryam AS was not a chaste woman.
2. Isa AS was drunkard and used to be with Prostitutes.
3. That he is the second coming of Muhammad PBUH and in face better than the first time.
4. He is God himself.
5. He is still a Muslim.
6. And anyone who does not accept him as a Prophet, is not a Muslim
regardless of whether someone has heard of him or not.
Can we accept that person to be a Muslim?
-
4 Replies
-
View About Mirza Qadiani
updated 4 months, 3 weeks ago
3 Members
·
4
Replies
-
I am surprised what we have or anyone else has to do with which other believes….
Only we will have discussion on ayah of khatme nabuwwat…..
Regarding his beliefs according to me it were circumtances around which resulted dawah of a person such….but being muslim your beliefs should not be changed or altered by circumtances but only by Qurans correct interpretation.
-
What are you trying to say here? Not able to understand a single sentence.
-
He is saying that in his opinion it is not important what other people like Qadiani believe (like e.g the Hazrat Isa parts you listed). Only thing that matters and worthy of discussion is the finality of Prophethood verse in the Qur’an in this topic.
He further explains his opinion that Qadiani’s beliefs were a product of his time and circumstances which is not a correct approach for a Muslim. A correct approach for Muslim is that he should shape his beliefs based on a proper understanding of Qur’an.
-
-
From what I understand, Ghamidi Sahab would consider point 1, 3 and 4 as kufr because it goes against what Allah Himself said in Qur’an and his major point that there is no revelations (in any form) after the Last Prophet PBUH. Anyone who claim otherwise is mistaken and needs correction or if they admit they are lying then they have committed kufr. Kindly see these discussions for more detail:
However Ghamidi Sahab does not believe that any Muslim has right to declare anyone kafir as it is a right solely for Allah. To understand his arguments in detail about this and any group committing kufr in general, kindly watch his series on takfir.
Discussion 59660For his view on Mirza general, the following discussions and video might be useful (the 3/3 part that comes after this is also relevant if you are interested for more):
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WwVhjhrMOjw
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
