A Community Driven Discussion Portal
To Ask, Answer, Share And Learn
Recently I have studied the philosophy of materialism . One of these materialists called eliminative materialists who are in minority thinks that conciousnessis all an illusion . The evidence they give is that when anything thing happens like after storytelling there is a release of oxytocin and we think that it is something amazing but there is no such thing . When we do anything it s just neuron firings in brain which we think as a conciousness . Its quite confusing because if that is illusion then everything experience by us is illusion. How I can understand it?
it is just an idea, a baseless rather absurd. The actual world is a reality. we experience it all the time. When one throws a ball in the air and the other catch it. it is a common experience of reality.
Faisal bhai I have already read it and listen to the whole series of zavia ghamidi . Yeah we feel that these are our inner subjective state but science tell us the process behind that which is only hormonal release or neuron firings
It’s a misconception that science has proven anything in this regard. Eliminative materialism is just one of the many hypothetical claims. Some of these ideas in the field of philosophy of mind are packaged as science and cause confusion for the common people who do not understand the academic debate at a deeper level.
Still, the idea needs to be considered. There is scientific evidence behind it. Please looks at Quantum Particle physics; especially Double Slit Experiment.
If I am not mistaken, it proves that the physical world does not exist, but when a conscious being observes, it materializes. Basically partials behave like waves, but as soon as someone observes them, they act like particles (Even going back in time and changing results. The results only change when someone observes it).
Quran also states that this life is not real. It can be interpreted both ways and one way is that is not physically real.
There is not way to conclusively reject either.
In the academia currently quantum physics is completely disregarded in the context of this debate because science doesn’t yet fully understand quantum physics.
Jazak Allah hu khair faisal bhai
We’ll never get the full grasp in science or full knowledge in any field of study. Knowledge is unlimited and we know less than atom’s weight of knowledge. Currently we have relatively better grasp of Quantum physics and the science of sub-particles. These are no longer theories. So far we have made Quantum computers, Quantum cryptography, etc.
As you pointed out, science is already using QM in different areas. It is because it has great predictive power in it’s applications. However, science is yet to understand the fundamentals of QM, so they disregard it in the context of physicalism and consciousness debates. There’s no sense in trying to understand one unknown with the help of another.
Currently there are multiple explanations for QM, but none of them are very plausible. At this time the scientific community has adopted the mantra of “shut up and calculate” in reference to QM where they want to use it’s power without worrying about understanding it.
Necessary cookies are absolutely essential for the website to function properly. This category only includes cookies that ensures basic functionalities and security features of the website. These cookies do not store any personal information.
Any cookies that may not be particularly necessary for the website to function and is used specifically to collect user personal data via analytics, ads, other embedded contents are termed as non-necessary cookies. It is mandatory to procure user consent prior to running these cookies on your website.