-
مقامات ارتیکل نمبر 30 (Quran Taking Precedence Over Words Of Prophets)
In the book of Sir. Ghamidi named (مقامات) Article Number 30 (مسلمانون کا زوال) line 14 he has stated that ” …ایمان و عقیدہ اور دین و شریعت کے تمام معاملات میں یہی(قران) مرجع بنے، ہر تحقیق، ہر راے اور ہر نقطۂ نظر کو ہمیشہ اِس کے تابع رکھا جائے، یہاں تک کہ خدا کے پیغمبروں کی کوئی بات بھی اِس پر حکم نہ سمجھی جائے، بلکہ ہر چیز پر اِسی کو حکم مانا جائے…” here he says Even the words of God’s messengers should not be taken as a rule cant” why not? Prophet words on religious affairs are it self revelation of Allah (وحی) this is what Ustad Ghamidi himself accepts.
could some one explain it in the view of Sir Ghamidi
Regards,
-
3 Replies
-
مقامات ارتیکل نمبر 30 (Quran Taking Precedence Over Words Of Prophets)
updated 2 years, 5 months ago
3 Members
·
3
Replies
-
Since, Quran hasnt changed over time and there is no confusion about it to be word of God. Hence, every thing will be judged according to it. Hadith literature has not reached us through twatur its historical record. If we come across any Prophetic saying we will understand it under the light of Quran. You will find following thread helpful
Discussion 1042-
Thank you dear Jalal, but I am curios that we have Mutawater Ahadith too, how could we explain it ?
-
Please watch this video from 19:34 to 32:30
-
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi
