Ask Ghamidi

A Community Driven Discussion Portal
To Ask, Answer, Share And Learn

Forums Forums Epistemology and Philosophy Do Muslims Worship Kaba?

  • Do Muslims Worship Kaba?

    Posted by ashif ahmed on June 1, 2022 at 10:51 am

    meine ek hindu se bat Kari thi usne accept nhi Kiya murti puja nehi hei sanatan dharam me lekin usne kaha ki woh murti ki nehi murti ko concentration ke liye use karte hei meine jab kaha yeh bhi galat hei toh usne reply Kiya ki kya kaba ko bhi hum concentration ke liye use nehi karte aur aise bat bohot age badh gayi phir meine usko bohot samjhya ki kaba ek direction hei tab woh bhi kehne laga ki murti bhi direction hei kaba ka maksad kya hei Asal me kya kaba ke bina namaz ho sakta hei agar direction kahi aur karke namaz ada kare agar nehi toh kya kaba bhi concentration ke liye use Kiya jata hei us taraf Rukh

    Umer replied 2 years, 1 month ago 3 Members · 11 Replies
  • 11 Replies
  • Do Muslims Worship Kaba?

    Umer updated 2 years, 1 month ago 3 Members · 11 Replies
  • Fatima

    Member June 1, 2022 at 4:25 pm

    unse pochiye ke kya hamary banane wale ne matlab khuda ne ye kaha hai ki usy concentrate karne keliye uski shakal banai jaye nahi,balki unhi ki kitaab me likha hai ke us khuda ki koi murti or pratima nahi to usko kyu nahi manty,or kaba ko concentrate samne rehkar to nahi balki puri duniya me kahin bhi ho vaha se karty hai kya vo bhi aisa karty hai ye concentrate ki baat nahi hai unity ki baat hai,or agar aap aise jagah ho jaha direction ka sahi pata naho to aap kisi rukh bhi namaaz ada karsakty hai jaise rasool Allah savari pe baithe hue bhi namaaz parlety the jabki savari ka rukh change bhi hota rahta tha.umeed hai hamne aaki baat sahi samjhi hai.

  • ashif ahmed

    Member June 1, 2022 at 7:01 pm

    @Fatima mene bohot samjhya ek aam muslim hone ke nate jitna samjga saku utna samjha Diya aur yeh jo ap keh rahe hei ek bacche bache ko pata hei muslims ke aur isiliye mene bhi yehi samjhaya lekin jid par ada hua tha aur meine direction ki sari ayat e jitna mere paas the sabhi diya tha yeh baat abhi thodi purani ho chuki hei par alhamdulillah meine apne tasalli ke mutabiq jawab diya woh log Jan buj kar Islam ko attack karna chahta hei India me apko sayad pata nehi hoga yaha par kuch log propaganda kar rahe hei Islam ke khilaf lekin ache log bhi ho log soye hue ho unko neend se utha sakte hei lekin Jo Jan bujkar akh band kar le uska toh allah hee hisap kare agar woh tauba na kare toh

  • ashif ahmed

    Member June 1, 2022 at 7:04 pm

    *** typing mistake usne accept kar liya tha ki murti puja nehi hei unke dharam me par kyo hota hei uske jawab me usne yeh concentrate wala argument diya

  • Fatima

    Member June 1, 2022 at 9:11 pm

    har kisi ko muslim banane ke piche kyu pare hue hai ham agar unhe sab pata hai to behas karne ka kya matlab or unke dharm ki bhi izzat kare shayad isse vo log zyaada samjhe,or mujhe pata nahi ki jo mei keh rahi ho vo bachcha bachcha janta hai mujhe maaf kariega maine sawal samjha or jawab diya

  • ashif ahmed

    Member June 1, 2022 at 10:02 pm

    nehi behen isme mafi mangne wali koi bat nehi apne kuch galat nehi kaha sayad mei hee apko samjha nehi paya actually yeh bat ek YouTube channel par shuru hui thi jaha par ek bhai athist o ke jawab deta hei Jo khudko so called ex muslim kehte hei aur islam ke against propaganda karte hei aur waha un so called ex muslim o ko sanatani log support karte hei donation karte hei mujhe isse koi problem nehi hei mein khud sabhi insan o ko ijjat ki nigahon se dekhta hu accept jo mere sat zyadti kare par jab hamare momin bhai unke allegations ka jawab dete hei waha par sanatani akar comments me ulta pulta kehte rehte hei isiliye meine usko reply Kiya tha taki aur bad me discussion ki baat Hui thi aur apko Jo mene kaha tha ki bacha bacha janta hei isiliye kaha tha yeh bat toh sach hei mein bhi wohi manta hu aur apne jo kaha tha meine bhi usko pehle isi tarah samjhaya tha aur yeh bat har muslims jante hei lekin unlogo ko kyo bata nehi hei is point of view se meine kaha tha bacha bacha janta hei aur hum sabhi toh muslim ke hee bacha hri isi tarah har koi janta hei sorry agar mere alfaaz se apko bura laga ho

  • Fatima

    Member June 2, 2022 at 12:02 am

    ex muslim hone ke unki apni wajah hai,hamare molvio ne deen ko pata nahi konsi dimension se samjha hai jiski wajah se musalmaan balki hamary apne bachche bhi yahi sawal karty hai,jaise hazrat aisha ki age,parda,dharhi,slavery women aapki apni milkiyat jo chahe kare,hadees o me tamam behayaai ki baaten bhari pari hai,ispe ghaur nahi karty ke jo aise baaten batae vo hadees nahi ho sakti lakin hamary molvi aisa sochne wale ko hi islam se nikaal dety hai,janab ghamidi sahab ne in sawalo ka kitna behtareen jawab diya hai magar unhe hi hadeeso ka munkir,ghalat interpret or unki khamiya dhondenge magar,hadeeso pe quraan ke translation pe review nahi karenge jabki ye maanenge ke ye kitaab qayamat tak ke liye hai phir bhi jo ghuzre zamaane ke chand logo ne samjha hai vo hi sahi hai

    • ashif ahmed

      Member June 2, 2022 at 8:10 am

      @Fatima ji par humein bhi logo ki galtiyon ko galt kehna chahiye logo ko galat nehi aur islamic history ( hadith) sahi bhi hoti hei galat bhi yeh toh Alim o ka kam aur mein ghamidi sab ko bhi ek Alim hee manta hu aur bohot hee badein badein Alim guzrein hei mei sabhi ki bat nehi kar raha bohot acche Alim bhi the lekin galti toh sabhi se ho sakta hei logo ko taqlid se bahar nikal kar tehqiq ki ribayat hona chahiye

  • Umer

    Moderator June 2, 2022 at 6:49 am
  • ashif ahmed

    Member June 2, 2022 at 8:56 am

    in this video ghamidi sab said Black stone jo hei woh allah ke hath ki alamat hei kya yeh shirk nehi hei allah ke ehed ke alamat bhi samjha ja sakta hei par allah toh kehta allah ke koi mishal nehi nehi toh hath ke mishal kaise ho sakta hei …?

    • Umer

      Moderator June 4, 2022 at 1:02 am

      Allah ka haath nhi hai, aik alamat hai insan kai samajhnay kai liya jai jaisay hath main hath dai kar tajdeed-e-ehad kiya jaata hai, waisay hi hajr-e-aswad ko woh alamat qarar diya gaya hai. Hajr-e-Aswad ko Allah ka haath kehna asal main aik haqeeqat ka tamseeli bayan.

  • ashif ahmed

    Member June 2, 2022 at 9:07 am

    @UmerQureshi aur please quran me bhi kya allah ke hath ki alamat wali bat hei black stone ke bare me

You must be logged in to reply.
Login | Register