Extension Of Concession Of Marriage With People Of The Book
hello Assallam u alaikum,
my question is that here in this answer of this thread
@UmerQureshi as sir umer said that if marriage with woman is allowed then it automatically means marriage with ahl e kitab men is not allowed. so can this ayat be interpreted that, since only woman of ahl e kitab is mentioned here. so if a new monotheist religion forms today called XYZism, so this non ahl e kitab (even if they are monotheist and also don’t have corrupted shirk beliefs like christians), their woman would still be not allowed. even if for example they live under total Muslim dominance (like the christians and Jews at that time of prophet), and they are monotheist, then still marriage to their woman is not allowed because they are not among ahl e kitab groups.
would such an interpretation be valid?
In the last 1231 days, 6,277 registered users have posted 50,025 messages under 12,926 unique topics on Ask Ghamidi.