-
Were Adam And Eve Not Living In Paradise Before Being Moved Out?
Assalam Alaikum,
I recently came across Ghamidi sahab claiming Adam/Eve (as) were not really in Paradise but some garden within the Earth?
My question is,
(1) Doesn’t it idea contradict with 7:24 where Allah (swt) then asks them to descend/move out (to where?) to “Earth” ! Obviously they were not on Earth.
(2) “Jannah” in that same context is mentioned 28 times in the Quran, and Each time it meant “Paradise”.. then why is it that just one time (7:19) Ghamidi sahab is confident that it would have a different meaning? Quran is very consistent with the choice and use of words.
Please address my two arguments above. Kindly do not send any links/videos.
jazakAllah khair!
Hasan
Sponsor Ask Ghamidi