Session – Dated 16th August 2020:

Question-01: Clarification on Quran’s Verse (4:34) i.e. ‘Husband’s right to punish the Wife’:

Discussion 1265 • Reply 1265

Question-02: Who are Khulifa-e-Rashideen (The rightly guided Caliphs) mentioned in the Hdith and what does following their Sunnah mean in that particular Hadith? What are their numbers?

Discussion 23325 • Reply 24280

Question-03: Majority of people in the world don’t clean pubic hair and perform circumcision, then how is it to be established that it is a part of human nature / fitrat?

Discussion 20624 • Reply 24276

Session – Dated 22nd August 2020:

Question-01: What does this Hadith mean?

“The best people are those of my generation, and then those who will come after them, and then those who will come after them…”

Discussion 6753 • Reply 26334

Session – Dated 23rd August 2020:

Question-01: Regarding Quran’s linguistic style involving sudden change of immediate addressees:

Discussion 26218 • Reply 26911

Session – Dated 29th August 2020:

Question-01: Is eating Lizard (Goh) halal?:

Discussion 26077 • Reply 28859

Question-02: Why weak chain of narrators for historical narrations in Ghamidi Sahab’s Book Meezan?:

Discussion 28527 • Reply 28626

Question-03: Principle of Sadd-e-Zariya, its application and its limits:

Discussion 6015 • Reply 28861

Question-04: Is eating Niyaaz of Moharram Halal?:

Discussion 28150 • Reply 28863

Session – Dated 13th September 2020:

Question-01: Praying Namaze-e-Janaza individually:

Discussion 25422 • Reply 30790

Question-02: Why Ibrahim عليه السلام asked forgiveness for His parents?:

Discussion 29649 • Reply 30803

Question-03: Authenticity of narration on Salah–with each Salah associated with a different Prophet?:

Discussion 28576 • Reply 30791

Question-04: Does soul have a gender?:

Discussion 30605 • Reply 30792

Discussion 30605 • Reply 37179

Question-05: Is is allowed to cull animals?:

Discussion 30618 • Reply 30793

Session – Dated 20th September 2020:

Question-01: Punishment of Castration for rapists:

Discussion 30809 • Reply 31188

Question-02: Zakat applicable on whole amount or the amount over and above nisaab threshold:

Discussion 988 • Reply 31187

Discussion 988 • Reply 36937

Question-03: How will the presence of degrees/levels in Paradise/Jannah bring ultimate satisfaction to a human being?:

Discussion 30128 • Reply 31189

Question-04: A Muslim involved in business of making coffins for Christians with a cross or statue of Jesus (AS) engraved on them:

Discussion 31031 • Reply 31190

Session – Dated 27th September 2020:

Question-01: Can something Haram be committed to save society from bigger Fasad. For example, to collect evidence of murder (which will convincingly prove the crime) through stealing or other illegal means to keep the murderer behind bars?:

Discussion 31059 • Reply 31703

Question-02: Issue of Piracy and Copyrights infringements both digital and otherwise:

Discussion 31559 • Reply 31705

Question-03: Sweepstakes and Earning (points, tokens, rewards etc.) through watching advertisements:

Discussion 7281 • Reply 31707

Question-04: Can Prayer/Salah be offered wearing a lungi for men and Saari for women?:

Discussion 31359 • Reply 31709

Session – Dated 04th October 2020:

Question-01: (i) Credit card late surcharge, why can’t the same late surcharge be imposed in case of ordinary lending activities? (ii) Principal-secured financing seems an unfair arrangement and will only favour the capitalist:

Discussion 32158 • Reply 32440

Question-02: Commission given by pharmaceutical companies to doctors for prescribing their medicines:

Discussion 31814 • Reply 32441

Question-03: In a society where bribery and tax evasion are so common that a person running his own business at times has no other option but to evade tax in order to stay competitive in the market:

Discussion 31275 • Reply 32442

Question-04: Definition of Bidah and saying Juma Mubarak to each other:

Discussion 32115 • Reply 32443

Session – Dated 11th October 2020:

Question-01: I own a convenience store in the U.S and there is a lottery machine installed in its terminal through which I earn lottery commission depending upon its usage:

Discussion 32157 • Reply 33113

Question-02: Ghamidi Sahab’s opinion on interest earned through bank deposits or bank saving accounts:

Discussion 32234 • Reply 33115

Question-03: Surah Rum, verse 27

وَهُوَ ٱلَّذِى يَبۡدَؤُاْ ٱلۡخَلۡقَ ثُمَّ يُعِيدُهُۥ وَهُوَ أَهۡوَنُ عَلَيۡهِۚ وَلَهُ ٱلۡمَثَلُ ٱلۡأَعۡلَىٰ فِى ٱلسَّمَٰوَٰتِ وَٱلۡأَرۡضِۚ وَهُوَ ٱلۡعَزِيزُ ٱلۡحَكِيمُ

It says that second creation is easier for Allah, should this be taken in literal sense?:

Discussion 32722 • Reply 33117

Question-04: Surah Yusuf, Verse 42

وَقَالَ لِلَّذِى ظَنَّ أَنَّهُۥ نَاجٍ مِّنۡهُمَا ٱذۡكُرۡنِى عِندَ رَبِّكَ فَأَنسَىٰهُ ٱلشَّيۡطَٰنُ ذِكۡرَ رَبِّهِۦ فَلَبِثَ فِى ٱلسِّجۡنِ بِضۡعَ سِنِينَ

Did Satan actually make the prisoner forget about Yusuf (AS)?:

Discussion 32401 • Reply 33118

Question-05: What is Fidya for leftover fasts which cannot be completed due to permanent illness?:

Discussion 32197 • Reply 33119

Question-06: Does blood from a wound renders Salah or wuzu ineffective?:

Discussion 31720 • Reply 33120

Session – Dated 18th October 2020:

Question-01: Pets neutering that is practiced now a days:

Discussion 33132 • Reply 33806

Question-02: Offering extra ruku and sujood in nafal salah:

Discussion 33538 • Reply 33807

Session – Dated 01st November 2020:

Question-01: Ghamidi sahab mentions that there are only two ways to answer something like what France did- respond in a diplomatic manner or, if you have power, call war. Is the persistent blasphemy that they committed a justifiable cause for war? If so, under what principle?:

Discussion 34592 • Reply 34990

Question-02: If we can use force (if we have force) against such countries that promote blasphemy, then why can’t we force them not to insult Islam by taking actions like boycotting, protesting etc. How come its begging?:

Discussion 34524 • Reply 34991

Session – Dated 07th November 2020:

Question-01: There was recently new dress code issued by a big Pakistani Bank requiring all women to do Hijab, wear loose clothing and apply minimal makeup and jewelry while describing it as a mandatory modest dressing in accordance with cultural norms:

Discussion 34336 • Reply 35454

Session – Dated 15th November 2020:

Question-01: As per Ghamidi Sahab, we can keep a fast and do some extra khairaat (charity) on 12th rabi-ul-awwal but we cannot offer nafal Salah. When we can keep a nafal fast and do some extra khairaat then how come offering of nafal salah comes under Bidah?:

Discussion 34962 • Reply 35872

Question-02: If maiz was given punishment of stoning/rajam in accordance with muharbha /fasad fil arz verses, then why did prophet Muhammad (sws) announce his forgiveness on the day of judgement/qiyamah?:

Discussion 34827 • Reply 35873

Question-03: Surah Hajj, verse 31, there is a metaphor used to describe the menace of Shirk i.e. metaphors like “fell from the sky“, “Bird picked at him” and “Wind blew him away”. What is the linguistic relevance of these metaphors in response to orientalists claiming these as very absurd and irrelevant examples?:

Discussion 32978 • Reply 35874

Question-04: If a woman willingly takes the financial responsibility of the home, can she then become the head of the family? Will she then be required to pay Mehar to the husband instead?:

Discussion 35593 • Reply 35875

Sessions – Dated 5th & 6th December 2020:

Question-01: Why did Ibless (Satan) challenge Allah Almighty and His authority when he saw Allah with naked eyes and was aware of the consequences even better than us humans?:

Discussion 35995 • Reply 37111

Question-02: Can a Muslim involve in creating, reading and sharing of jokes which involve God by any mean, even the ones not offensive on the face of it?:

Discussion 36772 • Reply 37112

Question-03: The practice of taking oath on Quran:

Discussion 36768 • Reply 37113

Question-04: Why is there no Tazkiya requirement for fish when we know that they also contain ‘flowing blood’ in them whenever they are cut alive?:

Discussion 36696 • Reply 37114

Discussion 36696 • Reply 37115

Question-05: Surah Maida, verses 33-34, there are two conditions for Muharbah Punishment i.e. ‘Waging war against Allah and His Prophet AND strive to spread anarchy in the land’. The presence of this ‘AND‘ suggests that both these conditions are needed in order to execute someone under Muharbah offence, and the first condition of waging war against Allah and His Prophet is time-specific because this condition can never be fulfilled in today’s time:

Discussion 32487 • Reply 37116

Question-06: Can we commercialize surrogacy and what are its limits, if any?:

Discussion 36979 • Reply 37117

Question-07: Can we enforce treatment on a cancer patient in case he/she refuses to take medical treatment?:

Discussion 36835 • Reply 37118

Session – Dated 12th December 2020:

Question-01: How to interpret Ahadith in which killing of both parties involved in homosexual act has been ordained?:

Discussion 37348 • Reply 37728

Question-02: Quran says that everything is doing Allah’s Hamd (Tasbih) but we don’t understand their language. Doesn’t the act of praising God (i.e. doing tasbih) require some kind of consciousness at the end of the person (or thing) doing it? While Animals on the other hand do not possess consciousness. How to corroborate these two facts?:

Discussion 37467 • Reply 37729

Question-03: Regarding splitting of the moon incident (Waqia Shaq-e-Qamar) mentioned in Quran; why is it that we find no historical evidence as it being witnessed by significant amount of other people around the globe as well?:

Discussion 37404 • Reply 37730

Question-04: In Surah Saaffaat: For Prophet ilyas (sws), why has Allah used ilyaseen for Him, which is plural?:

Discussion 36130 • Reply 37731

Sessions – Dated 26th & 27th December 2020:

Question-01: What is status of Qul, Chehlum and Chaliswaan in Islam?:

Discussion 38008 • Reply 39272

Question-02: If the whole of Salah has been transmitted to us through ijma and tawatur, then why is there difference between different sects in determination of timing for Asar Salah?:

Discussion 38439 • Reply 39274

Question-03: In Singapore, the government is of Non-Muslims, but a Constitutional institution, Majlis Ulama Islam, Singapore, organizes Juma salah, what would be the status of this Juma Salah?:

Discussion 37698 • Reply 39275

Session – Dated 09th January 2021:

Question-01: Surah Younas, Verse 96 states that only Prophet Younas’ (sws) nation professed faith in Allah and no other nation ever professed faith in the history of messengers (Rusul)? Doesn’t this verse contradict Ghamidi Sahab’s take on nation of Prophet Ismael (sws)?:

Discussion 38809 • Reply 40496

Question-02: The credit card has a credit limit of $X. The bank has given the facility to convert 80% of this credit limit into cash (say $Y = $X*0.8). The cash amount $Y can be used for any purpose. While paying back the cash amount $Y in 12 – 60 monthly installments, the bank also charge ‘monthly handling charges (say $Z)’ with each monthly installment. Do these monthly handling charges $Z count as Sood?:

Discussion 38840 • Reply 40497

Question-03: ACell PRP – A treatment in which A Cell PRP (ACell Matristem) derived from Pig bladder is combined with the patients’ own blood plasma for restoring hair loss. Since it uses pig cell, is it haram in Islam?:

Discussion 38080 • Reply 40498

Question-04: Can the governments of countries lying on Arabian Peninsula celebrate religious festivals of Hindus, Christians and Jews at a state level?:

Discussion 37685 • Reply 40499

Session– Dated 16th April 2021:

Question: Why aren’t tarawih salah, congregational dua after jamat (congregational salah) and congregational Friday salah without sultan considered as bidah?:

Discussion 45013 • Reply 47615

Session– Dated 19th April 2021:

Question: How to distinguish between Farz (obligatory) and Mustahab/Nafal (optional) Sunnah from ijma and tawatur?:

Discussion 47454 • Reply 47800

Session – Dated 29th August 2021:

Question: If someone makes a ‘will’ for his whole inheritance in favour of one Kalala relative based on some services rendered to him, is that ‘will’ subject to kalala distribution as mentioned in Quran where some portion will be distributed to the siblings of that Kalala relative or the whole ‘will’ in this case will be given to that particular Kalala relative in whose favour the ‘will’ has been made?:

Discussion 53087 • Reply 56422

Session – Dated 26th February 2022:

Question-01: Is there any ethical issue if one participates in clinical trials for different medicines and in addition to that, also takes money in return?:

Discussion 60849 • Reply 65263

Question-02: What was the need to give Quran a new final arrangement? If Quran is Sarguzisht-i-Anzar of the Prophet (sws), then why wasn’t original struggle and original phases of Prophet’s Dawah kept intact in their original order i.e. the way all the events unfolded and all the phases of Dawah were covered one by one?:

Discussion 57288 • Reply 65264

Question-03: As per Islamic Law of Inheritance, why is it that a sister gets more share than the wife of a deceased in case the deceased didn’t have any parents, children and siblings other than one or more than one sisters only? How is it that a sister is more beneficial for the deceased during his lifetime than the wife herself, how is this justice?:

Discussion 58080 • Reply 65266

Session – Dated 13th Match 2022:

Question: Views of Ghamidi Shaab on efforts to find prophecies and hindu religious scriptures and establishing their correlation with Islam by different Islamic scholars:

Discussion 58045 • Reply 65973